If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the FAQ by clicking the link above. You may have to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below. |
|
|
|
Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#1
|
|||
|
|||
On Wed, 2 Jul 2003 19:21:21 +0100
"John Smith" wrote: Hi, Whilst I hear the WD 120GB Special Edition drives with 8MB Cache are super fast I also hear they are super noisy and prone to high pitched whine. But, I hear some of the newer Seagates, although quiet, are lacking in performance - 120GB SATA is not that hot so I have read - and people are beginning to talk about the Samsung drives as being super-quiet. Anyone have any first hand info on this? I've got two Samsungs in my Tivo--they seem to be just a hair louder than the Seagates in my PC. I have another machine with a WD drive--that drive was noisy at first, but I moved it to a different bay to change the resonant frequency of the assembly and it quieted right down. Still not as quiet as the Seagates. At first I thought they had failed to start. Also, I hear that the IBM/Hitachis are considered good now but, um, after hearing about those faulty IBMs a year or so back and the issues people had with them I have drawn a mental line through buying them ever again. Did Hitachi over-come the IBM issues? That's a religious matter. You won't find reliable answers. Thanks, J. -- -- --John Reply to jclarke at ae tee tee global dot net (was jclarke at eye bee em dot net) |
#2
|
|||
|
|||
Quiet Drives, Fast Drives - WD, Seagate, Samsung & Hitachi
Hi,
Whilst I hear the WD 120GB Special Edition drives with 8MB Cache are super fast I also hear they are super noisy and prone to high pitched whine. But, I hear some of the newer Seagates, although quiet, are lacking in performance - 120GB SATA is not that hot so I have read - and people are beginning to talk about the Samsung drives as being super-quiet. Anyone have any first hand info on this? Also, I hear that the IBM/Hitachis are considered good now but, um, after hearing about those faulty IBMs a year or so back and the issues people had with them I have drawn a mental line through buying them ever again. Did Hitachi over-come the IBM issues? Thanks, J. |
#3
|
|||
|
|||
On Wed, 2 Jul 2003 21:08:45 +0100
"John Smith" wrote: Thanks - what Seagates do you have? Barracuda IV, 40 gig--the 80s are noisier in that series. J. "J.Clarke" wrote in message ... On Wed, 2 Jul 2003 19:21:21 +0100 "John Smith" wrote: Hi, Whilst I hear the WD 120GB Special Edition drives with 8MB Cache are super fast I also hear they are super noisy and prone to high pitched whine. But, I hear some of the newer Seagates, although quiet, are lacking in performance - 120GB SATA is not that hot so I have read - and people are beginning to talk about the Samsung drives as being super-quiet. Anyone have any first hand info on this? I've got two Samsungs in my Tivo--they seem to be just a hair louder than the Seagates in my PC. I have another machine with a WD drive--that drive was noisy at first, but I moved it to a different bay to change the resonant frequency of the assembly and it quieted right down. Still not as quiet as the Seagates. At first I thought they had failed to start. Also, I hear that the IBM/Hitachis are considered good now but, um, after hearing about those faulty IBMs a year or so back and the issues people had with them I have drawn a mental line through buying them ever again. Did Hitachi over-come the IBM issues? That's a religious matter. You won't find reliable answers. Thanks, J. -- -- --John Reply to jclarke at ae tee tee global dot net (was jclarke at eye bee em dot net) -- -- --John Reply to jclarke at ae tee tee global dot net (was jclarke at eye bee em dot net) |
#4
|
|||
|
|||
On Wed, 2 Jul 2003 21:24:40 +0100
"John Smith" wrote: Thanks Rod, I am not up to date on these fluid bearing drives - the WDs aren't but the Seagates are? Using fluids is down to, what exactly, elminate the whine or to cut down noise generally? Fluid Dynamic Bearings. Ball and roller bearings have lots of little bitty pieces that spin around and if any of them is just the slightest bit out of true or picks up the tiniest bit of crud then they make a noise. Fluid dynamic bearings have only one moving part, the shaft, or its attached bushings. They are designed to work with a specific lubricant that maintains a continuous film in normal operation, hence no vibration sources and less noise. Further, since there is in normal operation no metal-to-metal contact they last longer. Western Digital has a white paper on their site which states that they are going to go to fluid dynamic bearings on their entire line, but there's no timetable or list of models so equipped. Nonetheless it does have a good short description of the technology http://www.wdc.com/en/library/eide/2579-001052-000.pdf. J. "Rod Speed" wrote in message ... John Smith wrote in message ... Whilst I hear the WD 120GB Special Edition drives with 8MB Cache are super fast I also hear they are super noisy Nope. and prone to high pitched whine. Can happen given that they are the last of the non fluid bearing drives. But, I hear some of the newer Seagates, although quiet, are lacking in performance - 120GB SATA is not that hot so I have read - and people are beginning to talk about the Samsung drives as being super-quiet. Anyone have any first hand info on this? The latest range is really too recent to be able to say much on noise developing over time. There isnt even much around review wise yet. Also, I hear that the IBM/Hitachis are considered good now but, um, after hearing about those faulty IBMs a year or so back and the issues people had with them I have drawn a mental line through buying them ever again. Did Hitachi over-come the IBM issues? They certainly never fessed up to what the problem was. Its too early to tell what the story with the 180GXPs will be reliability wise. And they still have a hopeless RMA system where they wont preship the replacement with a credit card required to protect them against you not returning the one thats died. That alone puts them in the bin as far as I am concerned. I wouldnt buy a drive from an operation like that unless it left the alternatives for dead feature wise, and they dont. -- -- --John Reply to jclarke at ae tee tee global dot net (was jclarke at eye bee em dot net) |
#5
|
|||
|
|||
Thanks - what Seagates do you have?
J. "J.Clarke" wrote in message ... On Wed, 2 Jul 2003 19:21:21 +0100 "John Smith" wrote: Hi, Whilst I hear the WD 120GB Special Edition drives with 8MB Cache are super fast I also hear they are super noisy and prone to high pitched whine. But, I hear some of the newer Seagates, although quiet, are lacking in performance - 120GB SATA is not that hot so I have read - and people are beginning to talk about the Samsung drives as being super-quiet. Anyone have any first hand info on this? I've got two Samsungs in my Tivo--they seem to be just a hair louder than the Seagates in my PC. I have another machine with a WD drive--that drive was noisy at first, but I moved it to a different bay to change the resonant frequency of the assembly and it quieted right down. Still not as quiet as the Seagates. At first I thought they had failed to start. Also, I hear that the IBM/Hitachis are considered good now but, um, after hearing about those faulty IBMs a year or so back and the issues people had with them I have drawn a mental line through buying them ever again. Did Hitachi over-come the IBM issues? That's a religious matter. You won't find reliable answers. Thanks, J. -- -- --John Reply to jclarke at ae tee tee global dot net (was jclarke at eye bee em dot net) |
#6
|
|||
|
|||
Thanks Rod,
I am not up to date on these fluid bearing drives - the WDs aren't but the Seagates are? Using fluids is down to, what exactly, elminate the whine or to cut down noise generally? J. "Rod Speed" wrote in message ... John Smith wrote in message ... Whilst I hear the WD 120GB Special Edition drives with 8MB Cache are super fast I also hear they are super noisy Nope. and prone to high pitched whine. Can happen given that they are the last of the non fluid bearing drives. But, I hear some of the newer Seagates, although quiet, are lacking in performance - 120GB SATA is not that hot so I have read - and people are beginning to talk about the Samsung drives as being super-quiet. Anyone have any first hand info on this? The latest range is really too recent to be able to say much on noise developing over time. There isnt even much around review wise yet. Also, I hear that the IBM/Hitachis are considered good now but, um, after hearing about those faulty IBMs a year or so back and the issues people had with them I have drawn a mental line through buying them ever again. Did Hitachi over-come the IBM issues? They certainly never fessed up to what the problem was. Its too early to tell what the story with the 180GXPs will be reliability wise. And they still have a hopeless RMA system where they wont preship the replacement with a credit card required to protect them against you not returning the one thats died. That alone puts them in the bin as far as I am concerned. I wouldnt buy a drive from an operation like that unless it left the alternatives for dead feature wise, and they dont. |
#7
|
|||
|
|||
Thanks Rod, the whine is an issue for me on a 120GB 2MB Cache WD that I have
so I think I will opt for a Seagate. They have some made with FD motors but I can find no mention of fluid. J. "Rod Speed" wrote in message ... John Smith wrote in message ... Thanks Rod, I am not up to date on these fluid bearing drives - the WDs aren't but the Seagates are? Basically all except the WDs can be fluid bearing now, including the Samsungs. With Maxtor they can be either. Using fluids is down to, what exactly, elminate the whine Yep. or to cut down noise generally? Nope. "Rod Speed" wrote in message ... John Smith wrote in message ... Whilst I hear the WD 120GB Special Edition drives with 8MB Cache are super fast I also hear they are super noisy Nope. and prone to high pitched whine. Can happen given that they are the last of the non fluid bearing drives. But, I hear some of the newer Seagates, although quiet, are lacking in performance - 120GB SATA is not that hot so I have read - and people are beginning to talk about the Samsung drives as being super-quiet. Anyone have any first hand info on this? The latest range is really too recent to be able to say much on noise developing over time. There isnt even much around review wise yet. Also, I hear that the IBM/Hitachis are considered good now but, um, after hearing about those faulty IBMs a year or so back and the issues people had with them I have drawn a mental line through buying them ever again. Did Hitachi over-come the IBM issues? They certainly never fessed up to what the problem was. Its too early to tell what the story with the 180GXPs will be reliability wise. And they still have a hopeless RMA system where they wont preship the replacement with a credit card required to protect them against you not returning the one thats died. That alone puts them in the bin as far as I am concerned. I wouldnt buy a drive from an operation like that unless it left the alternatives for dead feature wise, and they dont. |
#8
|
|||
|
|||
"John Smith" wrote in message
... Hi, Whilst I hear the WD 120GB Special Edition drives with 8MB Cache are super fast I also hear they are super noisy and prone to high pitched whine. But, I hear some of the newer Seagates, although quiet, are lacking in performance - 120GB SATA is not that hot so I have read - and people are beginning to talk about the Samsung drives as being super-quiet. Anyone have any first hand info on this? Also, I hear that the IBM/Hitachis are considered good now but, um, after hearing about those faulty IBMs a year or so back and the issues people had with them I have drawn a mental line through buying them ever again. Did Hitachi over-come the IBM issues? I had one of the dodgy 75GXP drives (a 45 gig) and IBM/Hitachi replaced it with a brand new 60gig 120GXP, even though mine was already 2 years into it's warranty and they'd just started one year warranties (R.I.P. 3 year warranties). So despite what someone else said about IBM warranties, they're OK by me, especially compared to those cheating scumbags at Maxtor (but that's another story). Thanks, J. |
#9
|
|||
|
|||
Thanks - that's explains alot.
J. "J.Clarke" wrote in message ... On Wed, 2 Jul 2003 21:24:40 +0100 "John Smith" wrote: Thanks Rod, I am not up to date on these fluid bearing drives - the WDs aren't but the Seagates are? Using fluids is down to, what exactly, elminate the whine or to cut down noise generally? Fluid Dynamic Bearings. Ball and roller bearings have lots of little bitty pieces that spin around and if any of them is just the slightest bit out of true or picks up the tiniest bit of crud then they make a noise. Fluid dynamic bearings have only one moving part, the shaft, or its attached bushings. They are designed to work with a specific lubricant that maintains a continuous film in normal operation, hence no vibration sources and less noise. Further, since there is in normal operation no metal-to-metal contact they last longer. Western Digital has a white paper on their site which states that they are going to go to fluid dynamic bearings on their entire line, but there's no timetable or list of models so equipped. Nonetheless it does have a good short description of the technology http://www.wdc.com/en/library/eide/2579-001052-000.pdf. J. "Rod Speed" wrote in message ... John Smith wrote in message ... Whilst I hear the WD 120GB Special Edition drives with 8MB Cache are super fast I also hear they are super noisy Nope. and prone to high pitched whine. Can happen given that they are the last of the non fluid bearing drives. But, I hear some of the newer Seagates, although quiet, are lacking in performance - 120GB SATA is not that hot so I have read - and people are beginning to talk about the Samsung drives as being super-quiet. Anyone have any first hand info on this? The latest range is really too recent to be able to say much on noise developing over time. There isnt even much around review wise yet. Also, I hear that the IBM/Hitachis are considered good now but, um, after hearing about those faulty IBMs a year or so back and the issues people had with them I have drawn a mental line through buying them ever again. Did Hitachi over-come the IBM issues? They certainly never fessed up to what the problem was. Its too early to tell what the story with the 180GXPs will be reliability wise. And they still have a hopeless RMA system where they wont preship the replacement with a credit card required to protect them against you not returning the one thats died. That alone puts them in the bin as far as I am concerned. I wouldnt buy a drive from an operation like that unless it left the alternatives for dead feature wise, and they dont. -- -- --John Reply to jclarke at ae tee tee global dot net (was jclarke at eye bee em dot net) |
#10
|
|||
|
|||
Thanks for your help all - I ordered a Seagate VII 120GB with 8MB Cache
today. I don't know much about Samsungs of yet, although people say they are very quiet, and was a bit concerned how reliable they are. A friend has a Seagate VII and you can barely hear it right next to it. J. "Li'l ol' me" wrote in message ... "John Smith" wrote in message ... Hi, Whilst I hear the WD 120GB Special Edition drives with 8MB Cache are super fast I also hear they are super noisy and prone to high pitched whine. But, I hear some of the newer Seagates, although quiet, are lacking in performance - 120GB SATA is not that hot so I have read - and people are beginning to talk about the Samsung drives as being super-quiet. Anyone have any first hand info on this? Also, I hear that the IBM/Hitachis are considered good now but, um, after hearing about those faulty IBMs a year or so back and the issues people had with them I have drawn a mental line through buying them ever again. Did Hitachi over-come the IBM issues? I had one of the dodgy 75GXP drives (a 45 gig) and IBM/Hitachi replaced it with a brand new 60gig 120GXP, even though mine was already 2 years into it's warranty and they'd just started one year warranties (R.I.P. 3 year warranties). So despite what someone else said about IBM warranties, they're OK by me, especially compared to those cheating scumbags at Maxtor (but that's another story). Thanks, J. |
|
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
Seagate Redesigns Drives (with 73GB to 300GB capacities) | Ablang | General | 0 | May 23rd 04 04:01 AM |
FX-51 - recommended head sink/ fan combo? Want quiet but fast | Scotter | Overclocking AMD Processors | 5 | January 6th 04 10:51 PM |
Qty (30) Seagate ST34572W 4GB Hard Drives for Sale | Jay Willis | General Hardware | 0 | November 4th 03 04:28 PM |
Silent Computer - Advice | David Taylor | General | 49 | October 7th 03 11:26 AM |
Silent Computer - Advice | David Taylor | Homebuilt PC's | 51 | October 7th 03 11:26 AM |