If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the FAQ by clicking the link above. You may have to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below. |
|
|
|
Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#1
|
|||
|
|||
Using laptop as a desktop replacement--good idea?
Power user, willing to spend around $2000, but seriously can you use a
laptop as a desktop replacement? Last I looked into this issue, about 10 years ago, the answer was no, because of excessive heat concerns. At that time I had (and am still using!) a Dell Inspiron series Pentium II laptop (that is heavy but gets the job done--I still use it, as it has a 56k modem in it). I might be setting up another office (my third!) and I'm thinking, because the room itself is very small, that a laptop could be used as a desktop replacment, but maybe it's better if I spend $500 and get one of those entry level desktops. So the more general question is: what gives you more bang for the buck: a $500 desktop or a $2000 laptop for heavy duty use? The latter will outperform the former, but only on performance indexes, but long term the former is more easy to service and is (I guess) 70% of the power of the latter, which for me is good enough. Right now BTW I am writing software via Visual Studio using XP Prof on a Pentium IV! Slow, but it gets the job done. RL |
#2
|
|||
|
|||
Using laptop as a desktop replacement--good idea?
Ray,
It sounds like you already know all the things you should be considering. Generally I'd say yes, modern laptops are PC replacment capable. You don't have to spend $2k on a good one. I have an HP-HDX configured to my specs that's about a year old. It cost $1250 and has done everything I ask of it with no problems. Its running vista home premium, has 4gs of memory, and a 320gb hard drive, a 12 cell battery, TV tuner, antenna to pick up HDTV off the air, web cam, mic, numberic keypad, satae port, 3 usb ports, HDMI port, etc., oh yeah, and a high def screen that added $175 to the price. Also has a fingerprint reader to turn it on. It runs nowhere near as hot as my 4 year old compaq. So, if space is the consideration, a laptop is the answer. If upgrading and maintenance is the overriding concernern then a regular pc is the answer becausse it is so much easier to service, especially if you have to replace the motherboard. Hal "RayLopez99" wrote in message ... Power user, willing to spend around $2000, but seriously can you use a laptop as a desktop replacement? Last I looked into this issue, about 10 years ago, the answer was no, because of excessive heat concerns. At that time I had (and am still using!) a Dell Inspiron series Pentium II laptop (that is heavy but gets the job done--I still use it, as it has a 56k modem in it). I might be setting up another office (my third!) and I'm thinking, because the room itself is very small, that a laptop could be used as a desktop replacment, but maybe it's better if I spend $500 and get one of those entry level desktops. So the more general question is: what gives you more bang for the buck: a $500 desktop or a $2000 laptop for heavy duty use? The latter will outperform the former, but only on performance indexes, but long term the former is more easy to service and is (I guess) 70% of the power of the latter, which for me is good enough. Right now BTW I am writing software via Visual Studio using XP Prof on a Pentium IV! Slow, but it gets the job done. RL |
#3
|
|||
|
|||
Using laptop as a desktop replacement--good idea?
RayLopez99 raylopez88 gmail.com wrote:
Power user, willing to spend around $2000, but seriously can you use a laptop as a desktop replacement? Last I looked into this issue, about 10 years ago, the answer was no, because of excessive heat concerns. A laptop is not a home built computer. The answer is clearly No here because my homebuilt PC is perpetually home built. There is no comparison when talking about upgrades. You can find a wide range of components for desktop for much less money. -- RL Path: news.astraweb.com!border1.newsrouter.astraweb.com! npeer02.iad.highwinds-media.com!news.highwinds-media.com!feed-me.highwinds-media.com!postnews.google.com!k17g2000yqb.googlegr oups.com!not-for-mail From: RayLopez99 raylopez88 gmail.com Newsgroups: alt.comp.hardware.pc-homebuilt Subject: Using laptop as a desktop replacement--good idea? Date: Fri, 26 Mar 2010 02:50:21 -0700 (PDT) Organization: http://groups.google.com Lines: 22 Message-ID: 3690dd51-da0f-4f73-8d07-e834927fff3c k17g2000yqb.googlegroups.com NNTP-Posting-Host: 94.71.1.202 Mime-Version: 1.0 Content-Type: text/plain; charset=ISO-8859-1 X-Trace: posting.google.com 1269597021 27962 127.0.0.1 (26 Mar 2010 09:50:21 GMT) X-Complaints-To: groups-abuse google.com NNTP-Posting-Date: Fri, 26 Mar 2010 09:50:21 +0000 (UTC) Complaints-To: groups-abuse google.com Injection-Info: k17g2000yqb.googlegroups.com; posting-host=94.71.1.202; posting-account=fRZa_AkAAACE3nlFA9zM1Eq00OKq1Ycq User-Agent: G2/1.0 X-HTTP-UserAgent: Opera/9.80 (Windows NT 5.1; U; en) Presto/2.2.15 Version/10.10,gzip(gfe),gzip(gfe) |
#4
|
|||
|
|||
Using laptop as a desktop replacement--good idea?
On 3/26/2010 5:50 AM, RayLopez99 wrote:
Power user, willing to spend around $2000, but seriously can you use a laptop as a desktop replacement? Last I looked into this issue, about 10 years ago, the answer was no, because of excessive heat concerns. At that time I had (and am still using!) a Dell Inspiron series Pentium II laptop (that is heavy but gets the job done--I still use it, as it has a 56k modem in it). I might be setting up another office (my third!) and I'm thinking, because the room itself is very small, that a laptop could be used as a desktop replacment, but maybe it's better if I spend $500 and get one of those entry level desktops. So the more general question is: what gives you more bang for the buck: a $500 desktop or a $2000 laptop for heavy duty use? The latter will outperform the former, but only on performance indexes, but long term the former is more easy to service and is (I guess) 70% of the power of the latter, which for me is good enough. Right now BTW I am writing software via Visual Studio using XP Prof on a Pentium IV! Slow, but it gets the job done. RL For office applications and normal business/recreational computing a laptop is the the better choice, particularly if you don't spend any time "under the hood". It combines functionality with portability. And if you connect a real monitor you won't be missing anything. Where the desktop still rules is in graphics intensive programs where large or multiple video cards are needed, gaming where big graphics and cooling are key, and "extended use" machines that require additional peripherals and cards, multiple hard drives, etc. You figure out what the job is you need to do and pick the right tool to do it. |
#5
|
|||
|
|||
Using laptop as a desktop replacement--good idea?
On 3/26/2010 10:49 AM, John Doe wrote:
RayLopez99raylopez88 gmail.com wrote: Power user, willing to spend around $2000, but seriously can you use a laptop as a desktop replacement? Last I looked into this issue, about 10 years ago, the answer was no, because of excessive heat concerns. A laptop is not a home built computer. I beg to differ: http://www.zug.com/pranks/powerbook/ |
#6
|
|||
|
|||
Using laptop as a desktop replacement--good idea?
In article ,
RayLopez99 wrote: Power user, willing to spend around $2000, but seriously can you use a laptop as a desktop replacement? Last I looked into this issue, about 10 years ago, the answer was no, because of excessive heat concerns. At that time I had (and am still using!) a Dell Inspiron series Pentium II laptop (that is heavy but gets the job done--I still use it, as it has a 56k modem in it). Of course you can. Get a docking station (not expensive and cheap on eBay) Hoook a real kbd, mouse and monitor on it. Set the laptop up so it's screen is blank when it's in the dock. Advantages; The laptop will last longer. Items like the hinge and the screen backlight will not get as much abuse. It will run cooler becuase the power supply doesn't have to light the screen. You can leave the little power fob in the bag and won't forget it. If yu leave it somewhere, the dock gives you a spare. -- Al Dykes News is something someone wants to suppress, everything else is advertising. - Lord Northcliffe, publisher of the Daily Mail |
#7
|
|||
|
|||
Using laptop as a desktop replacement--good idea?
On Mar 26, 3:23*pm, "~hp-hdx~" wrote:
Thanks. Very interesting. I did not know a laptop could be so powerful. I like the fingerprint option too--with so many machines you start forgetting the passwords on each of them. HP is a good company, I was looking at their stuff and now in some areas they are cheaper than DELL (at the high end). Also do you think I should go for 64 bit Vista? From the net: "32bit operating systems can access a total of 2^32 (2 because machine code is .... 32 bit will only recognize up to 3.5 GB of RAM.... 64 bit will do 24 GB+! " RL |
#8
|
|||
|
|||
Using laptop as a desktop replacement--good idea?
On Mar 26, 5:49*pm, John Doe wrote:
A laptop is not a home built computer. The answer is clearly No here because my homebuilt PC is perpetually home built. There is no comparison when talking about upgrades. You can find a wide range of components for desktop for much less money. That's what I thought...but I dunno. What do you think is the price multiple, is a laptop 2x as costly as the same power desktop? Aside from the obvious service issues (and I've built many a desktop from scratch). Also: 64 bit or 32 bit Vista/ 7? RL |
#9
|
|||
|
|||
Using laptop as a desktop replacement--good idea?
On Mar 26, 8:47*pm, (Al Dykes) wrote:
In article , RayLopez99 wrote: Power user, willing to spend around $2000, but seriously can you use a laptop as a desktop replacement? *Last I looked into this issue, about 10 years ago, the answer was no, because of excessive heat concerns. At that time I had (and am still using!) a Dell Inspiron series Pentium II laptop (that is heavy but gets the job done--I still use it, as it has a 56k modem in it). Of course you can. Get a docking station (not expensive and cheap on eBay) Hoook a real kbd, mouse and monitor on it. *Set the laptop up so it's screen is blank when it's in the dock. Advantages; The laptop will last longer. *Items like the hinge and the screen backlight will not get as much abuse. * It will run cooler becuase the power supply doesn't have to light the screen. You can leave the little power fob in the bag and won't forget it. *If yu leave it somewhere, the dock gives you a spare. -- Al Dykes *News is something someone wants to suppress, everything else is advertising. * * - Lord Northcliffe, publisher of the Daily Mail Aha....so you are of the 'traditional' or 'classic' old school of thought that says (and I'm the same way) that laptops, since they use different chips in tighter spaces, run hotter (and probably slower) than desktops? Also: 64 bit OS or 32 bit OS--which do I pick? I'm leaning towards 64 bit, since in theory it should run all 32 bit programs as well, plus you can expand the RAM to beyond the 4GB limit. RL |
#10
|
|||
|
|||
Using laptop as a desktop replacement--good idea?
In article ,
RayLopez99 wrote: On Mar 26, 8:47=A0pm, (Al Dykes) wrote: In article = .com, RayLopez99 wrote: Power user, willing to spend around $2000, but seriously can you use a laptop as a desktop replacement? =A0Last I looked into this issue, about 10 years ago, the answer was no, because of excessive heat concerns. At that time I had (and am still using!) a Dell Inspiron series Pentium II laptop (that is heavy but gets the job done--I still use it, as it has a 56k modem in it). Of course you can. Get a docking station (not expensive and cheap on eBay) Hoook a real kbd, mouse and monitor on it. =A0Set the laptop up so it's screen is blank when it's in the dock. Advantages; The laptop will last longer. =A0Items like the hinge and the screen backlight will not get as much abuse. =A0 It will run cooler becuase the power supply doesn't have to light the screen. You can leave the little power fob in the bag and won't forget it. =A0If yu leave it somewhere, the dock gives you a spare. -- Al Dykes =A0News is something someone wants to suppress, everything else is advert= ising. =A0 =A0 - Lord Northcliffe, publisher of the Daily Mail Aha....so you are of the 'traditional' or 'classic' old school of thought that says (and I'm the same way) that laptops, since they use different chips in tighter spaces, run hotter (and probably slower) than desktops? "run hotter" is too vague. Try touching the heatsink on a desktop system. Yes. Cooler is better. Also: 64 bit OS or 32 bit OS--which do I pick? I'm leaning towards 64 bit, since in theory it should run all 32 bit programs as well, plus you can expand the RAM to beyond the 4GB limit. RL 64bit seems ready for prime-time and if you run lots of stuff at once, physical memory in excess of 4GB can speed things up, but as a generalization, any specific application can't use 4GB unless it's compiled for 64 bits. -- Al Dykes News is something someone wants to suppress, everything else is advertising. - Lord Northcliffe, publisher of the Daily Mail |
|
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
2 1g + 2 512meg = good idea ?? | student | Homebuilt PC's | 1 | July 20th 07 03:14 AM |
Desktop Replacement Laptop | John James - voice-bearer | Dell Computers | 2 | July 7th 06 03:27 PM |
Opteron 165 for gaming. This a good idea ?? | Miltion | AMD x86-64 Processors | 1 | January 16th 06 06:30 PM |
Opteron 165 for gaming. This a good idea ?? | Miltion | Homebuilt PC's | 1 | January 14th 06 10:25 AM |
Upgrade to 5700 good idea? | p00lb0y | Nvidia Videocards | 7 | August 24th 04 10:05 AM |