If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the FAQ by clicking the link above. You may have to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below. |
|
|
Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#1
|
|||
|
|||
Nvidia says Larrabee is Intel's reaction to CUDA
http://www.custompc.co.uk/news/60449...-to-cuda..html
Nvidia: Larrabee is a reaction to CUDA Posted at: 4:26pm 21st July 2008 by Ben Hardwidge Nvidia responds to Pat Gelsinger’s comments about CUDA being just a ‘footnote’ in computing history Intel may have put the wind up the graphics business with the development of its Larrabee graphics chip, but Nvidia reckons that Larrabee is just a reaction to what Nvidia has already achieved with its GPGPU CUDA technology. What’s more, the comments from Intel’s Pat Gelsinger earlier this month have also stirred up a debate about the future of multi-core programming. Nvidia’s general manager of its GPU computing group, Andy Keane, told Custom PC that the high level of interest in CUDA 'is causing Larrabee. Larrabee’s the reaction.’ He then added that ‘these comments from Gelsinger; if we were not making a lot of headway do you think he’d even give us a moment’s notice? No. It’s because he sees a lot of this activity. The strategy is to try to position it [CUDA] as something scary and unique, and it’s really not; it’s something that’s very accessible.’ Gelsinger said that CUDA would end up in the ‘interesting footnotes in the history of computing annals – they had great promise and there were a few applications that were able to take advantage of them.’ He then added that ‘generally an evolutionary compatible computing model, such as we’re proposing with Larrabee, we expect will be the right answer long term.’ However, Nvidia says that Gelsinger’s comments were misleading. ‘We use common languages,’ says Keane, ‘and this is where the Gelsinger information is totally misinformed, because it [CUDA] is standard C. It is actually the open 64 compiler which was originally designed for the Itanium – that’s our compiler. We’re actually using a CPU compiler, but we’ve given it a set of rules that basically say “if you write your program this way, it will scale across a few cores, or hundreds of cores.”’ ‘Industry standard languages always live,’ added Keane, ‘that’s kind of the misinformation from Gelsinger. We’re just C, and CUDA’s just a set of rules around C.’ Keane was also keen to point out that Intel was also behind the times when Anwar Ghuloum, a principal engineer with Intel's Microprocessor Technology Lab, said: ‘developers should start thinking about tens, hundreds, and thousands of cores now.’ ‘There’s the Gelsinger point, which is inconsistent in itself,’ said Keane, but there’s also the other guy who said that programmers should get ready for thousands of cores. Well, we already have a programming language; that’s the goal of CUDA. We’re already here with hundreds of cores - now we’re at 240 processor cores.’ Larrabee is a forthcoming discrete graphics chip from Intel that’s based on multiple x86 cores rather than stream processors. It will be compatible with standard 3D APIs, including DirectX and Open GL, but Gelsinger also promised ‘a broad set of new programming models to go with it.’ Many have speculated that Larrabee could also be used for ray tracing and physics calculations, as well as other tasks. Little is known about Larrabee yet, but more details will be released later this year at Siggraph. |
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
Intel Larrabee [speculation] to offer 16x the performance of GeForce8800 ? - Intel, Nvidia partnership to give Larrabee hardware rasterizingcapability? Larrabee could be useful for games | NV55 | Intel | 0 | December 19th 07 02:43 AM |
GPU Computing: Intel's Larrabee - AMD's Fusion - NVIDIA's Tesla + CUDA | NV55 | Intel | 0 | October 31st 07 12:21 AM |
GPU Computing: Intel's Larrabee - AMD's Fusion - NVIDIA's Tesla + CUDA | NV55 | AMD x86-64 Processors | 0 | October 31st 07 12:21 AM |
GPU Computing: Intel's Larrabee - AMD's Fusion - NVIDIA's Tesla + CUDA | NV55 | Nvidia Videocards | 0 | October 31st 07 12:21 AM |
GPU Computing: Intel's Larrabee - AMD's Fusion - NVIDIA's Tesla + CUDA | NV55 | Ati Videocards | 0 | October 31st 07 12:21 AM |