A computer components & hardware forum. HardwareBanter

If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the FAQ by clicking the link above. You may have to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below.

Go Back   Home » HardwareBanter forum » General Hardware & Peripherals » General
Site Map Home Register Authors List Search Today's Posts Mark Forums Read Web Partners

CPU heatsink/thermal compound



 
 
Thread Tools Display Modes
  #1  
Old December 22nd 04, 04:50 PM
Christo
external usenet poster
 
Posts: n/a
Default CPU heatsink/thermal compound

i think its tme to renew this stuff

is it easier to buy a new hs/fan with pre applied thermal compound or use
current hs/fan

i had pre applied thermal compound on it and its now very rouch and a bit
messy, temp is idle at 57 C on Socket A 2600+ not overclocked (previously,
when compound was new and hs/fan was new 42 C idle, it is a stock amd
cooler)

which is far too hot

so should i sand the bottom of the hs to get rid of the messy thermal
compound

and r apply some arctic silver?

what about the compound still on the core of the CPU, can i cleanr that off,
or should i leave?

with all this in mind would i not be better off buying a new hs/fan with
some more pre applied compound, hat with the arctic silver 5 costing and the
cost of a hs/fan with pre applied compound it may be cheaper to buy a whole
new hs/fan with pre applied compound

whats the best route to take


  #2  
Old December 22nd 04, 05:49 PM
kony
external usenet poster
 
Posts: n/a
Default

On Wed, 22 Dec 2004 15:50:40 -0000, "Christo"
wrote:

i think its tme to renew this stuff

is it easier to buy a new hs/fan with pre applied thermal compound or use
current hs/fan


Either is pretty easy, unless there's some unique situation
you're not disclosing.


i had pre applied thermal compound on it and its now very rouch and a bit
messy, temp is idle at 57 C on Socket A 2600+ not overclocked (previously,
when compound was new and hs/fan was new 42 C idle, it is a stock amd
cooler)


To anyone inquisitive enough to ask, I suggest removing the
original thermal compound, never using it. THEN, if
heatsink base is very rough, either replacing the 'sink or
lapping it a bit... not necessarily till it's like a mirror
but at least uniform, smooth.


which is far too hot

so should i sand the bottom of the hs to get rid of the messy thermal
compound


No, clean it off first with a plastic scraping tool (like
credit card) and petroleum solvent on a paper towel. Cheap
old silicone thermal compound can be used to buff out the
remaining bits of it.


and r apply some arctic silver?


Sure, or whatever... there's only a couple degrees
difference, primarily the benefit of the synthetic compounds
is that they're more resistant to heat, won't need reapplied
as often on a small, high-heat density core like an Athlon
XP.



what about the compound still on the core of the CPU, can i cleanr that off,
or should i leave?


Definitely clean it off.


with all this in mind would i not be better off buying a new hs/fan with
some more pre applied compound, hat with the arctic silver 5 costing and the
cost of a hs/fan with pre applied compound it may be cheaper to buy a whole
new hs/fan with pre applied compound

whats the best route to take


Clean off the original compound even on a new heatsink. If
you buy similar heatsink you'll get similar results
(assuming same thermal interface method), so either buy a
better heatsink than the original else there's no point to
it.

A different heatsink with 80-92mm x 25mm low-RPM fan would
be the quietest alternative, a stock-speed Athlon XP2600
isn't producing so much heat that it can't be cooled near
inaudibly with minimal effort, provided you use the right
fan. Usually that means buying a fan separately, but IIRC
Thermaltake's Silent Boost comes with a ribbed variant of a
Panaflo L1A which is pretty quiet to begin with but might
still be undervolted a bit.

Since you already have the original heatsink you might first
try cleaning it off, lightly lapping it, and applying
(whatever happens to be handy, that you already have)
heatsink grease. If the temps aren't low enough then
consider purchasing additional supplies. If you don't have
any higher-end thermal compound you might consider Arctic
Alumina or Ceramique, it's close enough in performance,
synthetic so it won't pump or dry out, and due to being
non-capacitive it'll be more useful for other heatsinking
like video card or motherboards, etc... Not to mention that
it's less expensive and easier to clean up.


  #3  
Old December 23rd 04, 01:24 AM
Christo
external usenet poster
 
Posts: n/a
Default


"kony" wrote in message
...
On Wed, 22 Dec 2004 15:50:40 -0000, "Christo"
wrote:

i think its tme to renew this stuff

is it easier to buy a new hs/fan with pre applied thermal compound or use
current hs/fan


Either is pretty easy, unless there's some unique situation
you're not disclosing.


i had pre applied thermal compound on it and its now very rouch and a bit
messy, temp is idle at 57 C on Socket A 2600+ not overclocked (previously,
when compound was new and hs/fan was new 42 C idle, it is a stock amd
cooler)


To anyone inquisitive enough to ask, I suggest removing the
original thermal compound, never using it. THEN, if
heatsink base is very rough, either replacing the 'sink or
lapping it a bit... not necessarily till it's like a mirror
but at least uniform, smooth.


which is far too hot

so should i sand the bottom of the hs to get rid of the messy thermal
compound


No, clean it off first with a plastic scraping tool (like
credit card) and petroleum solvent on a paper towel. Cheap
old silicone thermal compound can be used to buff out the
remaining bits of it.


and r apply some arctic silver?


Sure, or whatever... there's only a couple degrees
difference, primarily the benefit of the synthetic compounds
is that they're more resistant to heat, won't need reapplied
as often on a small, high-heat density core like an Athlon
XP.



what about the compound still on the core of the CPU, can i cleanr that
off,
or should i leave?


Definitely clean it off.


with all this in mind would i not be better off buying a new hs/fan with
some more pre applied compound, hat with the arctic silver 5 costing and
the
cost of a hs/fan with pre applied compound it may be cheaper to buy a
whole
new hs/fan with pre applied compound

whats the best route to take


Clean off the original compound even on a new heatsink. If
you buy similar heatsink you'll get similar results
(assuming same thermal interface method), so either buy a
better heatsink than the original else there's no point to
it.

A different heatsink with 80-92mm x 25mm low-RPM fan would
be the quietest alternative, a stock-speed Athlon XP2600
isn't producing so much heat that it can't be cooled near
inaudibly with minimal effort, provided you use the right
fan. Usually that means buying a fan separately, but IIRC
Thermaltake's Silent Boost comes with a ribbed variant of a
Panaflo L1A which is pretty quiet to begin with but might
still be undervolted a bit.

Since you already have the original heatsink you might first
try cleaning it off, lightly lapping it, and applying
(whatever happens to be handy, that you already have)
heatsink grease. If the temps aren't low enough then
consider purchasing additional supplies. If you don't have
any higher-end thermal compound you might consider Arctic
Alumina or Ceramique, it's close enough in performance,
synthetic so it won't pump or dry out, and due to being
non-capacitive it'll be more useful for other heatsinking
like video card or motherboards, etc... Not to mention that
it's less expensive and easier to clean up.



thanks great deal of help there, it should set me on the right track, like
you say larger fans would be quieter, which is an issue here too

I have been looking at a whole new hs/fan that being the Akasa AK-825

it isnt pretty but it sounds like it might be good enough for me, i
especially like the fact i can adjust fan speed which will allow for noise
lowering, to suit my requirements

Thanks kony


  #4  
Old December 23rd 04, 01:35 AM
Christo
external usenet poster
 
Posts: n/a
Default


"kony" wrote in message
...
On Wed, 22 Dec 2004 15:50:40 -0000, "Christo"
wrote:

i think its tme to renew this stuff

is it easier to buy a new hs/fan with pre applied thermal compound or use
current hs/fan


Either is pretty easy, unless there's some unique situation
you're not disclosing.


i had pre applied thermal compound on it and its now very rouch and a bit
messy, temp is idle at 57 C on Socket A 2600+ not overclocked (previously,
when compound was new and hs/fan was new 42 C idle, it is a stock amd
cooler)


To anyone inquisitive enough to ask, I suggest removing the
original thermal compound, never using it. THEN, if
heatsink base is very rough, either replacing the 'sink or
lapping it a bit... not necessarily till it's like a mirror
but at least uniform, smooth.


which is far too hot

so should i sand the bottom of the hs to get rid of the messy thermal
compound


No, clean it off first with a plastic scraping tool (like
credit card) and petroleum solvent on a paper towel. Cheap
old silicone thermal compound can be used to buff out the
remaining bits of it.


and r apply some arctic silver?


Sure, or whatever... there's only a couple degrees
difference, primarily the benefit of the synthetic compounds
is that they're more resistant to heat, won't need reapplied
as often on a small, high-heat density core like an Athlon
XP.



what about the compound still on the core of the CPU, can i cleanr that
off,
or should i leave?


Definitely clean it off.


with all this in mind would i not be better off buying a new hs/fan with
some more pre applied compound, hat with the arctic silver 5 costing and
the
cost of a hs/fan with pre applied compound it may be cheaper to buy a
whole
new hs/fan with pre applied compound

whats the best route to take


Clean off the original compound even on a new heatsink. If
you buy similar heatsink you'll get similar results
(assuming same thermal interface method), so either buy a
better heatsink than the original else there's no point to
it.

A different heatsink with 80-92mm x 25mm low-RPM fan would
be the quietest alternative, a stock-speed Athlon XP2600
isn't producing so much heat that it can't be cooled near
inaudibly with minimal effort, provided you use the right
fan. Usually that means buying a fan separately, but IIRC
Thermaltake's Silent Boost comes with a ribbed variant of a
Panaflo L1A which is pretty quiet to begin with but might
still be undervolted a bit.

Since you already have the original heatsink you might first
try cleaning it off, lightly lapping it, and applying
(whatever happens to be handy, that you already have)
heatsink grease. If the temps aren't low enough then
consider purchasing additional supplies. If you don't have
any higher-end thermal compound you might consider Arctic
Alumina or Ceramique, it's close enough in performance,
synthetic so it won't pump or dry out, and due to being
non-capacitive it'll be more useful for other heatsinking
like video card or motherboards, etc... Not to mention that
it's less expensive and easier to clean up.



by the way should i be using something like white spirit to clean the CPU?
or is that a no no, with it being flamable?

not sure what i should use to clean the core... any household items or am i
gonna need a trip to homebase or somewhere for some specialized cleaning
materials?


  #5  
Old December 23rd 04, 05:05 AM
kony
external usenet poster
 
Posts: n/a
Default

On Thu, 23 Dec 2004 00:35:52 -0000, "Christo"
wrote:



by the way should i be using something like white spirit to clean the CPU?
or is that a no no, with it being flamable?


Flammability is not a problem, but you dont' need anything
highly volatile either. I usually use "Goo Gone", which is
meant to get adhesive off of things, but other common
petroleum-based solvents would work, even gasoline or WD-40.



not sure what i should use to clean the core... any household items or am i
gonna need a trip to homebase or somewhere for some specialized cleaning
materials?



Same thing, petroleum-based solvent. Read labels of
cleaning /etc type products you already have, if it lists
"petroleum solvent" in the label it'll probably do the job.
If the thermal interface material is really thick and
stubbon on the CPU it may help to saturate a rag or paper
towel with solvent, put that against the top of the CPU and
seal it in a plastic bag to soak for a few hours. It's not
necessary but if you're not in a hurry it takes less effort
that way.
 




Thread Tools
Display Modes

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

vB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Forum Jump

Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
black patch/thermal compound on P4 jf General 1 July 29th 04 04:25 AM
Took off Heatsink and no thermal compound left any reason this would happen ? We Live For The One We Die For The One General 1 May 4th 04 03:19 AM
So what if thermal compound spreads? Will Dormann General 134 April 20th 04 12:51 PM
Thermal pad or Thermal paste? Vin General 68 September 17th 03 05:38 AM
Intel thermal pad or Arctic Silver? kony General 3 July 4th 03 12:35 AM


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 10:50 AM.


Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.6.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright ©2004-2024 HardwareBanter.
The comments are property of their posters.