If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the FAQ by clicking the link above. You may have to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below. |
|
|
Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#1
|
|||
|
|||
Advice please : Athlon2800 or 3200
About to replace my PIII 500 with either a 2800 or 3200 system.
Question is will I see a drastic difference considering it's £100 more expensive, or would I be better spending the £100 on say a DVD-RW. It's obviously going to be a massive improvement either way over my old system. If I go for the 2800, when prices drop will a 3200 chip simply drop into the same socket for an easy upgrade. Thanks in advance. |
#2
|
|||
|
|||
"seeker" wrote in message om... About to replace my PIII 500 with either a 2800 or 3200 system. Question is will I see a drastic difference considering it's £100 more expensive, or would I be better spending the £100 on say a DVD-RW. It's obviously going to be a massive improvement either way over my old system. If I go for the 2800, when prices drop will a 3200 chip simply drop into the same socket for an easy upgrade. Thanks in advance. Don't bother with either mate. Spend £65 on the XP2500 and immediately up the FSB to 200MHz (from 166Mhz) = instant XP3200 |
#3
|
|||
|
|||
On Tue, 11 Nov 2003 14:35:45 -0000, "nightic"
wrote: "seeker" wrote in message . com... About to replace my PIII 500 with either a 2800 or 3200 system. Question is will I see a drastic difference considering it's £100 more expensive, or would I be better spending the £100 on say a DVD-RW. It's obviously going to be a massive improvement either way over my old system. If I go for the 2800, when prices drop will a 3200 chip simply drop into the same socket for an easy upgrade. Thanks in advance. Don't bother with either mate. Spend £65 on the XP2500 and immediately up the FSB to 200MHz (from 166Mhz) = instant XP3200 And hope it remains stable :-) If it does then fair play go for it. I've seen enough machines that either a) had occasional crashes becuase they were overclocked or b) keeping them cool/upgrading memory cost a signinficant amount of the price difference and it wasn't worth the faffing around. I would go for the 2500 myself though and get the DVD-RW and if you have anything left buy extra memory. If it overclocks bonus, if it doesn't that speed difference between the 2500 & 2800 aint that much and you could always buy a 3200 in 6 months to a year for the price of a 2500 :-) I use a 1500XP and there is SFA that it can't do that I have found up to now. |
#4
|
|||
|
|||
"Baguss" wrote in message ... On Tue, 11 Nov 2003 14:35:45 -0000, "nightic" wrote: "seeker" wrote in message . com... About to replace my PIII 500 with either a 2800 or 3200 system. Question is will I see a drastic difference considering it's £100 more expensive, or would I be better spending the £100 on say a DVD-RW. It's obviously going to be a massive improvement either way over my old system. If I go for the 2800, when prices drop will a 3200 chip simply drop into the same socket for an easy upgrade. Thanks in advance. Don't bother with either mate. Spend £65 on the XP2500 and immediately up the FSB to 200MHz (from 166Mhz) = instant XP3200 And hope it remains stable :-) If it does then fair play go for it. I've seen enough machines that either a) had occasional crashes becuase they were overclocked or b) keeping them cool/upgrading memory cost a signinficant amount of the price difference and it wasn't worth the faffing around. I would go for the 2500 myself though and get the DVD-RW and if you have anything left buy extra memory. If it overclocks bonus, if it doesn't that speed difference between the 2500 & 2800 aint that much and you could always buy a 3200 in 6 months to a year for the price of a 2500 :-) I use a 1500XP and there is SFA that it can't do that I have found up to now. Honestly though it is a rare XP2500 that can't cope with 200 x 11. Very many can manage this at default voltage and those that can't typically require no more than 1.75V (we're talking for 24hrs Prime95 stable). The increase in temperature running at these speeds/voltages is not massive although £10-15 spent on upgrading the heatsink & fan (from the standard retail package's one) is advisable. Further, the price difference between a decent stick of PC2700 and PC3200 RAM is not so significant as to be a real issue IMO. |
#5
|
|||
|
|||
On Tue, 11 Nov 2003 15:06:06 -0000, "nightic"
wrote: snip Honestly though it is a rare XP2500 that can't cope with 200 x 11. Very many can manage this at default voltage and those that can't typically require no more than 1.75V (we're talking for 24hrs Prime95 stable). The increase in temperature running at these speeds/voltages is not massive although £10-15 spent on upgrading the heatsink & fan (from the standard retail package's one) is advisable. I'd upgrade the fan from the standard one simply becuase its such a PITA to fit the AMD HS :-) I preferr the "lever" type locking mechanisim rather than just streaching over that metal strap. I get nervous that I'm going to slip and gouge a chunk out the mobo :-) I've had and know of too many people who have had bad experiences with overclocked AMD machines so make it worth the hassle anymore. Further, the price difference between a decent stick of PC2700 and PC3200 RAM is not so significant as to be a real issue IMO. Yep I'd agree with the price difference for memory not being too much, unless you already have 2700 and have to ditch it. If its new memory I'd go for the fastest I could afford to safeguard it for the future. |
#6
|
|||
|
|||
Further, the price difference between a decent stick of PC2700 and PC3200
RAM is not so significant as to be a real issue IMO. Yep I'd agree with the price difference for memory not being too much, unless you already have 2700 and have to ditch it. If its new memory I'd go for the fastest I could afford to safeguard it for the future. Ack! I`ve just ordered... AMD AthlonXP 2500 [1.83GHZ 333] RET, Item Price = £60, Quantity = 1 ABit NF7-S , Item Price = £70, Quantity = 1 Chieftec Dragon Blue , Item Price = £39, Quantity = 1 Kingmax "Turbo" 512Mb 2700 Fast DDR, Item Price = £55, Quantity = 2 I won`t be able to overclock the 2500 with 2700 memory then? Maybe if I don`t open the ram packaging Aria would be kind enough to take it back and replace it with 3200? Damn, I thought I hadn`t messed up and made all right choices this time!!! |
#7
|
|||
|
|||
"uselesses" wrote in message ... Further, the price difference between a decent stick of PC2700 and PC3200 RAM is not so significant as to be a real issue IMO. Yep I'd agree with the price difference for memory not being too much, unless you already have 2700 and have to ditch it. If its new memory I'd go for the fastest I could afford to safeguard it for the future. Ack! I`ve just ordered... AMD AthlonXP 2500 [1.83GHZ 333] RET, Item Price = £60, Quantity = 1 ABit NF7-S , Item Price = £70, Quantity = 1 Chieftec Dragon Blue , Item Price = £39, Quantity = 1 Kingmax "Turbo" 512Mb 2700 Fast DDR, Item Price = £55, Quantity = 2 I won`t be able to overclock the 2500 with 2700 memory then? Maybe if I don`t open the ram packaging Aria would be kind enough to take it back and replace it with 3200? Damn, I thought I hadn`t messed up and made all right choices this time!!! Yep, they will, just cancel the RAM within 7 days of it's arrival and return it unopened. If they have yet to dispatch your order you maybe able to pre-empt this and upgrade to PC3200 now. |
#8
|
|||
|
|||
"nightic" wrote in message ... I won`t be able to overclock the 2500 with 2700 memory then? Maybe if I don`t open the ram packaging Aria would be kind enough to take it back and replace it with 3200? Damn, I thought I hadn`t messed up and made all right choices this time!!! Yep, they will, just cancel the RAM within 7 days of it's arrival and return it unopened. If they have yet to dispatch your order you maybe able to pre-empt this and upgrade to PC3200 now. I'd do it. The price difference is small, but you have more options in terms of overclocking and reusability in other systems with the faster memory. |
#9
|
|||
|
|||
"jeffc" wrote in message ... "nightic" wrote in message ... I won`t be able to overclock the 2500 with 2700 memory then? Maybe if I don`t open the ram packaging Aria would be kind enough to take it back and replace it with 3200? Damn, I thought I hadn`t messed up and made all right choices this time!!! Yep, they will, just cancel the RAM within 7 days of it's arrival and return it unopened. If they have yet to dispatch your order you maybe able to pre-empt this and upgrade to PC3200 now. I'd do it. The price difference is small, but you have more options in terms of overclocking and reusability in other systems with the faster memory. Can`t I just have the cpu fsb higher than the memory with the NF7? Even on this QDI Advance intel via board i got here i can underclock the ram FSB of 133 by 33mhz?? Argh!! Its already been dispatched it says.Guess i`ll get it tomorrow and decide wether to send the memory back or build my new PC with the 2700. |
#10
|
|||
|
|||
seeker wrote:
About to replace my PIII 500 with either a 2800 or 3200 system. Question is will I see a drastic difference considering it's £100 more expensive, or would I be better spending the £100 on say a DVD-RW. It's obviously going to be a massive improvement either way over my old system. If I go for the 2800, when prices drop will a 3200 chip simply drop into the same socket for an easy upgrade. Thanks in advance. Draw a graph of processor clock speed (X axis) against price (Y axis). You'll see a lovely exponential curve. You'll notice that the 3200 is much more expensive for not that much more money. Personally I'd be tempted to get a 2800 or 3000. Cheers, Chris Howells |
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
PL1600 and 3200 Controller | Adam Raff | Compaq Servers | 1 | November 26th 04 03:30 AM |
Help OVERCLOCKED barton 3200 at 2500 score | doomer | Overclocking AMD Processors | 3 | September 6th 04 11:13 PM |
Barton 2500 overlocked to 3200 and Normal 3200 barton which one should i get ? | We Live for the One we Die for the One | Overclocking AMD Processors | 11 | June 14th 04 11:58 PM |
Advice on components for a new PC | [email protected] | Homebuilt PC's | 7 | October 20th 03 03:36 AM |
Help with Epson 3200, Please! | Anonymous | Scanners | 2 | October 15th 03 01:54 AM |