If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the FAQ by clicking the link above. You may have to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below. |
|
|
Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#1
|
|||
|
|||
[Q] How can the physical environment slow a drive down?
I'm talking about a rackmount computer (Tyan GT24) with 4 drive cages
for SATA drives which plug into a backplane. If I have the drives laid out atop the computer with the SATA cables running over the open case into the RAID card, the drives are very fast (70-80 MB/second). Now if I merely install the drives into the drive cages in the rackmount while keeping them directly connected to the SATA cables (i.e., backplane removed), the drives are way slower (20-30 MB/second). This is very reproducible behavior and it occurs with not only our 750 GB Seagates but also with an Hitachi and WD. |
#2
|
|||
|
|||
[Q] How can the physical environment slow a drive down?
Maurice Volaski wrote:
I'm talking about a rackmount computer (Tyan GT24) with 4 drive cages for SATA drives which plug into a backplane. If I have the drives laid out atop the computer with the SATA cables running over the open case into the RAID card, the drives are very fast (70-80 MB/second). Now if I merely install the drives into the drive cages in the rackmount while keeping them directly connected to the SATA cables (i.e., backplane removed), the drives are way slower (20-30 MB/second). This is very reproducible behavior and it occurs with not only our 750 GB Seagates but also with an Hitachi and WD. One obvious way is when vibration disturbs the disk head enough to cause the drive to have to re-read data (in your case, since you're clearly streaming data it might have to retry a couple of times per revolution before it got everything right). This is reportedly one area in which 'enterprise' drives work better (i.e., are more resistant to such disturbance) than desktop drives, and people have specifically reported difficulties in multi-drive enclosures where mechanical coupling allowed one drive's vibration to affect other drives. No guarantee that this is what you're seeing, but it is one possibility. I suppose you could also be getting some kind of electrical interference in your cabling in the box that does not occur when the cables are spread around outside it, but it's more difficult to see how that could generate that level of performance loss that you're experiencing. I'm not sure whether 'S.M.A.R.T.' information in the drives includes data on the kinds of retries that vibration-related problems would produce, but it wouldn't hurt to take a look at before-and-after stats in both configurations. - bill |
#3
|
|||
|
|||
[Q] How can the physical environment slow a drive down?
In article OKadnSgQMPZDoGvYnZ2dnUVZ_hisnZ2d@metrocastcablevi sion.com,
Bill Todd wrote: Maurice Volaski wrote: I'm talking about a rackmount computer (Tyan GT24) with 4 drive cages for SATA drives which plug into a backplane. If I have the drives laid out atop the computer with the SATA cables running over the open case into the RAID card, the drives are very fast (70-80 MB/second). Now if I merely install the drives into the drive cages in the rackmount while keeping them directly connected to the SATA cables (i.e., backplane removed), the drives are way slower (20-30 MB/second). This is very reproducible behavior and it occurs with not only our 750 GB Seagates but also with an Hitachi and WD. One obvious way is when vibration disturbs the disk head enough to cause the drive to have to re-read data (in your case, since you're clearly streaming data it might have to retry a couple of times per revolution before it got everything right). This is reportedly one area in which 'enterprise' drives work better (i.e., are more resistant to such disturbance) than desktop drives, and people have specifically reported difficulties in multi-drive enclosures where mechanical coupling allowed one drive's vibration to affect other drives. No guarantee that this is what you're seeing, but it is one possibility. You are right. It's the fans. |
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
Physical hard drive failure. | [email protected] | Storage (alternative) | 17 | August 10th 05 11:42 PM |
how can I fix my hard drive. (physical damage I think) | [email protected] | Storage (alternative) | 7 | April 10th 05 05:26 AM |
Physical switch to disable a hard drive | Julian | General Hardware | 5 | January 26th 04 04:36 AM |
ASIC Physical Synthesis, Physical Compilation requirement in India, Bangalore | abdul | General Hardware | 0 | December 14th 03 11:48 AM |
Can You have FAT32 and NTFS partitions on the same physical drive? | Ron | Storage (alternative) | 1 | August 2nd 03 10:10 PM |