If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the FAQ by clicking the link above. You may have to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below. |
|
|
Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#1
|
|||
|
|||
P4-specific SDRAM?
This is old stuff but I'm curious. I always used AMD in the
Pentium 4 days and didn't pay much attention when I saw some SDRAMs being advertised as being for P4s. I happened to see it again today in a price list, one item being marked (PIV) among other 133 MHz SDRAMs. Can anybody please elaborate? |
#2
|
|||
|
|||
P4-specific SDRAM?
pawihte wrote:
This is old stuff but I'm curious. I always used AMD in the Pentium 4 days and didn't pay much attention when I saw some SDRAMs being advertised as being for P4s. I happened to see it again today in a price list, one item being marked (PIV) among other 133 MHz SDRAMs. Can anybody please elaborate? It's more fun with a question like this, if you include a URL. A Pentium 4 uses a chipset to interface to RAM. So it is the characteristics of the chipset that would be of interest. In the RAM business, there are a few cases where terms like "high density/low density" are used to describe RAM. For example, with PC133, there are 256MB high density (8 chips of 32Mx8) and 256MB low density (16 chips of 16Mx8) modules. Some older chipsets will only half address the high density ones. The chips used, have a different setup for rows * columns of the matrix. And that is what causes the problem. (It could have been solved, if the chipset designers had realized these eight chip modules would happen. But the standards only go so far, in defining what to expect.) There are SDRAM chipsets, that can handle larger modules, meaning more row/column bits. I think my 845 based P4 board can do that (Asus P4B). I have 3x512MB in it right now. I think it can even take 1GB PC133 modules. (The 845 chipset exists in SDRAM and DDR designs, and mine is an SDRAM design.) In DDR memory, when the modules are 1GB in size, there are high density and low density modules there as well. The number of chips may be 16 in each case. One module may use (16) 64Mx8 and that would be low density. The other would use (16) 128Mx4 chips. The first module contains two ranks of memory. The second (high density) one contains one rank. Some chipsets don't have sufficient address bits, to handle the rows * columns used at 128M. For example, Nforce2 can only half address the 128Mx4 chip. Since the high density modules are mostly sold on Ebay, it is easiest to just say "don't buy 1GB DDR modules on Ebay". Branded RAM makers won't sell high density modules, so the modules in question won't have a name like Corsair/Crucial/Kingston/OCZ/Geil etc. The Ebay vendors may call them "Samsung", but that is referring to the chips, as if the module is also made by Samsung. Chances are, the module is made by some small job shop in China. They fling around "Samsung" in the advert, to make it appear legitimate. (To me, the best RAM, is the RAM that works in any computer, not restricted to a limited group of chipsets.) As far as I know, there is no "leakage" of server chips (x4) into desktop applications, with DDR2 and DDR3. So at present, no need to be more wary of Ebay sellers, if DDR2 or DDR3 modules are offered. Just the usual quality concerns. There is nothing wrong with x4 wide chips. They belong on things like registered ECC or FBDIMM modules. They don't belong on desktops (if you check Intel desktop chipset datasheets, x4 are always excluded from their memory type list - they show x8 or x16 chips instead as the ones they want). HTH, Paul |
#3
|
|||
|
|||
P4-specific SDRAM?
Paul wrote:
pawihte wrote: This is old stuff but I'm curious. I always used AMD in the Pentium 4 days and didn't pay much attention when I saw some SDRAMs being advertised as being for P4s. I happened to see it again today in a price list, one item being marked (PIV) among other 133 MHz SDRAMs. Can anybody please elaborate? It's more fun with a question like this, if you include a URL. A Pentium 4 uses a chipset to interface to RAM. So it is the characteristics of the chipset that would be of interest. In the RAM business, there are a few cases where terms like "high density/low density" are used to describe RAM. For example, with PC133, there are 256MB high density (8 chips of 32Mx8) and 256MB low density (16 chips of 16Mx8) modules. Some older chipsets will only half address the high density ones. The chips used, have a different setup for rows * columns of the matrix. And that is what causes the problem. (It could have been solved, if the chipset designers had realized these eight chip modules would happen. But the standards only go so far, in defining what to expect.) There are SDRAM chipsets, that can handle larger modules, meaning more row/column bits. I think my 845 based P4 board can do that (Asus P4B). I have 3x512MB in it right now. I think it can even take 1GB PC133 modules. (The 845 chipset exists in SDRAM and DDR designs, and mine is an SDRAM design.) In DDR memory, when the modules are 1GB in size, there are high density and low density modules there as well. The number of chips may be 16 in each case. One module may use (16) 64Mx8 and that would be low density. The other would use (16) 128Mx4 chips. The first module contains two ranks of memory. The second (high density) one contains one rank. Some chipsets don't have sufficient address bits, to handle the rows * columns used at 128M. For example, Nforce2 can only half address the 128Mx4 chip. Since the high density modules are mostly sold on Ebay, it is easiest to just say "don't buy 1GB DDR modules on Ebay". Branded RAM makers won't sell high density modules, so the modules in question won't have a name like Corsair/Crucial/Kingston/OCZ/Geil etc. The Ebay vendors may call them "Samsung", but that is referring to the chips, as if the module is also made by Samsung. Chances are, the module is made by some small job shop in China. They fling around "Samsung" in the advert, to make it appear legitimate. (To me, the best RAM, is the RAM that works in any computer, not restricted to a limited group of chipsets.) As far as I know, there is no "leakage" of server chips (x4) into desktop applications, with DDR2 and DDR3. So at present, no need to be more wary of Ebay sellers, if DDR2 or DDR3 modules are offered. Just the usual quality concerns. There is nothing wrong with x4 wide chips. They belong on things like registered ECC or FBDIMM modules. They don't belong on desktops (if you check Intel desktop chipset datasheets, x4 are always excluded from their memory type list - they show x8 or x16 chips instead as the ones they want). HTH, Paul I saw the PIV spec from a price list I downloaded. I live in a small town in India, and though I don't buy from them I d/l their price list from time to time for use as a reference. Sort of a personal pricewatch.com. I just checked their website and they don't mention the PIV spec except on the downloadable price list. The URLs are - Home: http://www.computerwarehousepricelist.com Price list: http://www.computerwarehousepricelis...=Pricelist.xls Thanks a lot for the detailed explanation. I'm an electronics tech, mostly analog, and have a limited knowledge of digital and computer technology. But I can understand the concept of address bit width, matrices and module density after reading your patient explanation. My approach used to be that if a mobo/chipset is specced to be able/unable to use double-sided RAM sticks, I took that at face value. At least I knew that single-sided and double-sided do not have to literally mean the physical mounting of chips on one or both sides of the RAM pcb. |
#4
|
|||
|
|||
P4-specific SDRAM?
pawihte wrote:
Paul wrote: pawihte wrote: This is old stuff but I'm curious. I always used AMD in the Pentium 4 days and didn't pay much attention when I saw some SDRAMs being advertised as being for P4s. I happened to see it again today in a price list, one item being marked (PIV) among other 133 MHz SDRAMs. Can anybody please elaborate? It's more fun with a question like this, if you include a URL. A Pentium 4 uses a chipset to interface to RAM. So it is the characteristics of the chipset that would be of interest. In the RAM business, there are a few cases where terms like "high density/low density" are used to describe RAM. For example, with PC133, there are 256MB high density (8 chips of 32Mx8) and 256MB low density (16 chips of 16Mx8) modules. Some older chipsets will only half address the high density ones. The chips used, have a different setup for rows * columns of the matrix. And that is what causes the problem. (It could have been solved, if the chipset designers had realized these eight chip modules would happen. But the standards only go so far, in defining what to expect.) There are SDRAM chipsets, that can handle larger modules, meaning more row/column bits. I think my 845 based P4 board can do that (Asus P4B). I have 3x512MB in it right now. I think it can even take 1GB PC133 modules. (The 845 chipset exists in SDRAM and DDR designs, and mine is an SDRAM design.) In DDR memory, when the modules are 1GB in size, there are high density and low density modules there as well. The number of chips may be 16 in each case. One module may use (16) 64Mx8 and that would be low density. The other would use (16) 128Mx4 chips. The first module contains two ranks of memory. The second (high density) one contains one rank. Some chipsets don't have sufficient address bits, to handle the rows * columns used at 128M. For example, Nforce2 can only half address the 128Mx4 chip. Since the high density modules are mostly sold on Ebay, it is easiest to just say "don't buy 1GB DDR modules on Ebay". Branded RAM makers won't sell high density modules, so the modules in question won't have a name like Corsair/Crucial/Kingston/OCZ/Geil etc. The Ebay vendors may call them "Samsung", but that is referring to the chips, as if the module is also made by Samsung. Chances are, the module is made by some small job shop in China. They fling around "Samsung" in the advert, to make it appear legitimate. (To me, the best RAM, is the RAM that works in any computer, not restricted to a limited group of chipsets.) As far as I know, there is no "leakage" of server chips (x4) into desktop applications, with DDR2 and DDR3. So at present, no need to be more wary of Ebay sellers, if DDR2 or DDR3 modules are offered. Just the usual quality concerns. There is nothing wrong with x4 wide chips. They belong on things like registered ECC or FBDIMM modules. They don't belong on desktops (if you check Intel desktop chipset datasheets, x4 are always excluded from their memory type list - they show x8 or x16 chips instead as the ones they want). HTH, Paul I saw the PIV spec from a price list I downloaded. I live in a small town in India, and though I don't buy from them I d/l their price list from time to time for use as a reference. Sort of a personal pricewatch.com. I just checked their website and they don't mention the PIV spec except on the downloadable price list. The URLs are - Home: http://www.computerwarehousepricelist.com Price list: http://www.computerwarehousepricelis...=Pricelist.xls Thanks a lot for the detailed explanation. I'm an electronics tech, mostly analog, and have a limited knowledge of digital and computer technology. But I can understand the concept of address bit width, matrices and module density after reading your patient explanation. My approach used to be that if a mobo/chipset is specced to be able/unable to use double-sided RAM sticks, I took that at face value. At least I knew that single-sided and double-sided do not have to literally mean the physical mounting of chips on one or both sides of the RAM pcb. OK, in the price list, I see this "MEMORY DESKTOP RAM (MEMORY ) SD RAM 128 MB 133 MHZ (1YW) 256 MB 133 MHZ (1YW) 512 MB 133MHZ (1YW)( piv) " The 128MB would work on a 440BX (Pentium3) board. The 256MB would depend on whether it was high density or low density. The price list does not say whether the module is 8 or 16 chips. You'd want a 16 chip module, if the motherboard was 440BX. In the case of the 512MB SDRAM PC133, that is larger than a chipset like 440BX would use. They may be incorrect though, in that I think I do have a Pentium3 (socket 370) motherboard here, a TUV4X, that will take larger modules. So this one, might take those 512MB PC133 modules. http://www.baber.com/baber/411/asus_tuv4x.htm The modules would definitely work on my P4B 845 SDRAM motherboard, with S478 socket for a Pentium 4. So the descriptive terms in the pricelist, are a guide to the buyer, to be careful before buying. They should have placed a warning next to the 256MB modules as well, or at least indicated the chip count on the module. Many people have been fooled by 8 chip modules - the 8 chip ones are more common. You can get 16 chip modules from Crucial (that is where I got 256MB 16 chip modules for my 440BX based motherboard). http://www.crucial.com/store/mpartsp...8089FCA5CA7304 Paul |
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
power down with specific timing | daprezjer | Homebuilt PC's | 0 | March 2nd 07 01:16 PM |
Need recommendation for specific needs | Atreju | Webcams | 0 | November 22nd 06 11:37 PM |
Looking for a specific switch | Joris Dobbelsteen | General | 1 | October 31st 05 05:51 AM |
new 256Mb SDRAM won't work with other 256Mb SDRAM | fred | General | 10 | July 14th 05 03:29 AM |
Help, please - specific type of cd-r? | smh | Cdr | 3 | August 20th 04 06:45 AM |