If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the FAQ by clicking the link above. You may have to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below. |
|
|
Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#1
|
|||
|
|||
Wireless Keyboard and mouse suitable for gaming ?
Hi, I'm looking to buy a wireless mouse and keyboard to go with my system. Trouble is I've owned a wireless mouse before and whilst fine for office type applications, the reaction time is far to slow for games. This product was brought some time ago so I'm things have improved since then. Anybody got any suggestions reccomendations ? TIA. |
#2
|
|||
|
|||
"andyw"
wrote in oups.com: Hi, I'm looking to buy a wireless mouse and keyboard to go with my system. Trouble is I've owned a wireless mouse before and whilst fine for office type applications, the reaction time is far to slow for games. This product was brought some time ago so I'm things have improved since then. Anybody got any suggestions reccomendations ? TIA. Unless you are putting your keyboard out of reach of a normal corded keyboard, why use a cordless keyboard and have yet another set of batteries go dead? You start to wonder why you are missing keystrokes or the keyboard went dead. Some cordless keyboards and mice have their software popup a warning about "low battery" but that means you get your work interrupted. If you're going to put the system case far enough away that the keyboard's cord won't reach then cordless makes sense. But remember that you still must have the receiver and keyboard so they "see" each other. I don't know of any that use infrared anymore so direct line-of-sight isn't required, but you can't bury the receiver on the other side of the system case, behind the monitor, or anything else that might shield the RF between keyboard and receiver. For cordless mice, the weight of the batteries will make the mouse much heavier. You can get units that use AAA batteries but then you obviously have less charge and they drain faster. You might find your pinkie fatigues much faster having to squeeze the mouse when repeatedly having to lift and move it over (and one of the reasons why trackballs are sometimes preferred along with no interruption in movement or limitation in movement). However, unless you have a free area ahead of a corded mouse so its cord moves freely without hitting anything (to cause torque) and the cord slides freely (little resistance) then you might want cordless. If you are in an environment where you cannot guarantee at least 15 feet between multiple users of cordless keyboards and mice, stay with corded. Otherwise, you can end up with users wondering why their cursors are mysteriously wandering around their screen. I've even seen users interfere with each other that were 50 feet apart and one floor apart. I've had cordless keyboards but realized no benefit from it being cordless. I don't type with it on my lap or sitting in a recliner away from the computer. I did use a cordless mouse for a long time but had to give up due to pinkie fatigue (and overall fatigue) because of the extra weight. When I did have cordless, it was a Logitech. When it got broken, I decided to try other brands that were lighter. I tried the IBM (black) cordless mouse and Microsoft Blue cordless mouse. Both had problems never encountered with the Logitech. The IBM and Microsoft would go to sleep too soon. I was constantly moving the mouse only to find the cursor wouldn't start moving on the screen until 1 to 2 seconds after I had started moving the mouse; i.e., they would go to sleep too soon and had to be awakened but their poll interval to detect movement was too long. This conserved power but at the expense of response. Then IBM was worse (i.e., long wakeup lag) than the Microsoft. Both had jerky movement so bad within games that it was like I was running a low-speed shutter over my eyeballs while playing. You would miss something happening or overshoot. Syncing the device with the receiver didn't help. Upping the sampling rate (a property of the mouse device in Device Manager) would reduce the jerkiness but it was still pretty bad, so bad that I wouldn't bother playing my games. Although they were lighter and would reduce fatigue under long use, I had to go back to the Logitech cordless mouse. Even at the default (lowest) sampling rate, the Logitech was smooth during gameplay. However, it takes a lot longer for it to go into sleep mode and it polls much more quickly (so it will come out of sleep mode much more quickly) which results in shorter battery life. Alkaline batteries in the Logitech cordless mouse would last around 17 to 22 days when I was doing gaming for several hours an evening along with all my other normal work during the day. Rechargeable NiMH batteries lasted 14 to 17 days. Logitech claims that the batteries should last a couple months. Nope. With no gaming, the batteries might last 1 month. I had returned 4 of their cordless mice where even they thought they were defective. The IBM and Microsoft units would've lasted longer on batteries but I couldn't stand the bad response from them. There was one other cordless mouse but it was some generic brand that I don't recall (wasn't any worse than the IBM or Microsoft but it wasn't any better, and all were to laggy during gameplay and to slow to wakeup even during non-game use compared to the Logitech). If you don't get cordless devices with rechargeable batteries integrated into them (which means you also cannot [easily] replace them when they go stale), make sure to get 2 sets of rechargeable batteries for each device, and a charger. Then when the batteries get low, you can slide in the already charged set and start charging the depleted set so they are ready for the next swap. If you really need to get rid of the cord, remember the mouse will get heavier due to the battery weight and can accelerate fatigue. Batteries do deplete which means you'll get erratic behavior when they get low and eventually the device goes dead (and you could be right in the middle of something time critical). Some cordless units have software that will alert you when batteries are low, but you won't see that popup while playing a game, and you might be busy at the time and decide to do it later, forget, and end up with a dead device when you need it right now. Some cordless mice are just too jerky during gameplay and upping the sampling rate won't entirely eliminate the jerkiness. I have since switched from a cordless Logitech to a corded Logitech (to reduce fatigue) and subjectively I can't say that I've noticed a difference (i.e., improvement) in performance during gameplay. I might eventually go back to a trackball to eliminate the nuisance and fatigue of constantly having to pickup and move the mouse. -- __________________________________________________ _______________ ******** Post replies to newsgroup - Share with others ******** Email: lh_811newsATyahooDOTcom and append "=NEWS=" to Subject. __________________________________________________ _______________ |
#3
|
|||
|
|||
On 23 Sep 2004 01:26:16 -0700, "andyw"
wrote: Hi, I'm looking to buy a wireless mouse and keyboard to go with my system. Trouble is I've owned a wireless mouse before and whilst fine for office type applications, the reaction time is far to slow for games. This product was brought some time ago so I'm things have improved since then. Anybody got any suggestions reccomendations ? I think there's still a very slight lag but some people don't seem to notice it. If that's what you want you'll just have to try one. Try the Logitech MX series, separates or bundled, mainly the mouse need be MX for best gaming. They're sculpted for right-hand use though, which some people dislike even for right-handed use. They have improved over the past few years, but still the mouse is a bit heavy, I prefer a corded MX300 and still take the added metal weight (slug) out of it. |
#4
|
|||
|
|||
I am not crazy about wireless mouse and keyboards. I get very upset, when I
start getting the low battery warning while working for many hours with these. I would think that working by wire is the best and most reliable. If you stay with the wire types, you will also save a few dollars to get something that is more usable for your gaming. -- Jerry G. ========================== "andyw" wrote in message oups.com... Hi, I'm looking to buy a wireless mouse and keyboard to go with my system. Trouble is I've owned a wireless mouse before and whilst fine for office type applications, the reaction time is far to slow for games. This product was brought some time ago so I'm things have improved since then. Anybody got any suggestions reccomendations ? TIA. |
#5
|
|||
|
|||
Very informative post Van
I've been using cordless ball mouse for some time and would never go back. I agree though, that I wouldn't want a cordless keyboard. It's just too huge to be turned over and change the batteries on that. so I keep mine ps/2. For the logitech mouse though, I have the acceleration at "low" and slider all defaulted. I don't find myself constantly lifting, I don't lift at all actually. But if you're running resolution above 1600, you might need to lift it with default mousespeed. For the pad, this is important if you have a ball mouse, buy the 3M mouse surface. It's 8 times more expensive but it's worth it. It's clean and grabs the ball like mad. I clean it once every 6 months with running water. The surface traps dusts below the contact surface so there's no more need to clean the rollers or the ball. I am not kidding, I never need to clean my ball ever since I got this pad 3 years ago. For opticals, the newer opticals all have decent refresh rates, excluding the cheap ass no brand ones. When using optical mouses, use them on a light colored surface to maximize battery life and accuracy. I still find that the corded mx300 has a higher refresh rate than the cordless version. Yes the cordless is heavier. But the corded cord likes to bump into objects on the desks. Van, I love your concern on fatigue Worked for 9 hours in office, and go home for 4 hours of CS:CZ hehe. "Vanguardx" see_signature ??? ???... "andyw" wrote in oups.com: Hi, I'm looking to buy a wireless mouse and keyboard to go with my system. Trouble is I've owned a wireless mouse before and whilst fine for office type applications, the reaction time is far to slow for games. This product was brought some time ago so I'm things have improved since then. Anybody got any suggestions reccomendations ? TIA. Unless you are putting your keyboard out of reach of a normal corded keyboard, why use a cordless keyboard and have yet another set of batteries go dead? You start to wonder why you are missing keystrokes or the keyboard went dead. Some cordless keyboards and mice have their software popup a warning about "low battery" but that means you get your work interrupted. If you're going to put the system case far enough away that the keyboard's cord won't reach then cordless makes sense. But remember that you still must have the receiver and keyboard so they "see" each other. I don't know of any that use infrared anymore so direct line-of-sight isn't required, but you can't bury the receiver on the other side of the system case, behind the monitor, or anything else that might shield the RF between keyboard and receiver. For cordless mice, the weight of the batteries will make the mouse much heavier. You can get units that use AAA batteries but then you obviously have less charge and they drain faster. You might find your pinkie fatigues much faster having to squeeze the mouse when repeatedly having to lift and move it over (and one of the reasons why trackballs are sometimes preferred along with no interruption in movement or limitation in movement). However, unless you have a free area ahead of a corded mouse so its cord moves freely without hitting anything (to cause torque) and the cord slides freely (little resistance) then you might want cordless. If you are in an environment where you cannot guarantee at least 15 feet between multiple users of cordless keyboards and mice, stay with corded. Otherwise, you can end up with users wondering why their cursors are mysteriously wandering around their screen. I've even seen users interfere with each other that were 50 feet apart and one floor apart. I've had cordless keyboards but realized no benefit from it being cordless. I don't type with it on my lap or sitting in a recliner away from the computer. I did use a cordless mouse for a long time but had to give up due to pinkie fatigue (and overall fatigue) because of the extra weight. When I did have cordless, it was a Logitech. When it got broken, I decided to try other brands that were lighter. I tried the IBM (black) cordless mouse and Microsoft Blue cordless mouse. Both had problems never encountered with the Logitech. The IBM and Microsoft would go to sleep too soon. I was constantly moving the mouse only to find the cursor wouldn't start moving on the screen until 1 to 2 seconds after I had started moving the mouse; i.e., they would go to sleep too soon and had to be awakened but their poll interval to detect movement was too long. This conserved power but at the expense of response. Then IBM was worse (i.e., long wakeup lag) than the Microsoft. Both had jerky movement so bad within games that it was like I was running a low-speed shutter over my eyeballs while playing. You would miss something happening or overshoot. Syncing the device with the receiver didn't help. Upping the sampling rate (a property of the mouse device in Device Manager) would reduce the jerkiness but it was still pretty bad, so bad that I wouldn't bother playing my games. Although they were lighter and would reduce fatigue under long use, I had to go back to the Logitech cordless mouse. Even at the default (lowest) sampling rate, the Logitech was smooth during gameplay. However, it takes a lot longer for it to go into sleep mode and it polls much more quickly (so it will come out of sleep mode much more quickly) which results in shorter battery life. Alkaline batteries in the Logitech cordless mouse would last around 17 to 22 days when I was doing gaming for several hours an evening along with all my other normal work during the day. Rechargeable NiMH batteries lasted 14 to 17 days. Logitech claims that the batteries should last a couple months. Nope. With no gaming, the batteries might last 1 month. I had returned 4 of their cordless mice where even they thought they were defective. The IBM and Microsoft units would've lasted longer on batteries but I couldn't stand the bad response from them. There was one other cordless mouse but it was some generic brand that I don't recall (wasn't any worse than the IBM or Microsoft but it wasn't any better, and all were to laggy during gameplay and to slow to wakeup even during non-game use compared to the Logitech). If you don't get cordless devices with rechargeable batteries integrated into them (which means you also cannot [easily] replace them when they go stale), make sure to get 2 sets of rechargeable batteries for each device, and a charger. Then when the batteries get low, you can slide in the already charged set and start charging the depleted set so they are ready for the next swap. If you really need to get rid of the cord, remember the mouse will get heavier due to the battery weight and can accelerate fatigue. Batteries do deplete which means you'll get erratic behavior when they get low and eventually the device goes dead (and you could be right in the middle of something time critical). Some cordless units have software that will alert you when batteries are low, but you won't see that popup while playing a game, and you might be busy at the time and decide to do it later, forget, and end up with a dead device when you need it right now. Some cordless mice are just too jerky during gameplay and upping the sampling rate won't entirely eliminate the jerkiness. I have since switched from a cordless Logitech to a corded Logitech (to reduce fatigue) and subjectively I can't say that I've noticed a difference (i.e., improvement) in performance during gameplay. I might eventually go back to a trackball to eliminate the nuisance and fatigue of constantly having to pickup and move the mouse. -- __________________________________________________ _______________ ******** Post replies to newsgroup - Share with others ******** Email: lh_811newsATyahooDOTcom and append "=NEWS=" to Subject. __________________________________________________ _______________ |
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
quirky MS wireless mouse behavoir | MajBach1 | General | 2 | April 2nd 04 06:44 AM |
Logitech Wireless Keyboard w/ Microsoft Wireless Mouse?? | Chuck Dreier | General | 2 | March 10th 04 09:22 AM |
Logitech Bluetooth Wireless Keyboard & Mouse | Richard Carlson | General | 0 | February 8th 04 05:05 AM |
Wireless Optical Mouse and Keyboard with Belkin Omniview SE KVM | Wayne Morgan | General | 0 | January 15th 04 03:53 AM |
Gyration Wireless Keyboard and Mouse ? | Barry Rubin | General | 0 | October 11th 03 01:21 PM |