If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the FAQ by clicking the link above. You may have to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below. |
|
|
|
Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#1
|
|||
|
|||
Power supplies?
It's possibly time to upgrade my power supply. Haven't shopped around
for one in ages. What's the new features that I have to look for these days? My last PS was a 450W ATX from maybe 5 years ago. I expect my new one would have to be at least 500W now. I'm thinking I should get one with the low-speed 120 mm fans. And maybe one with a motherboard fan speed connector? Yousuf Khan |
#2
|
|||
|
|||
Power supplies?
Yousuf Khan wrote:
:: It's possibly time to upgrade my power supply. Haven't shopped :: around for one in ages. What's the new features that I have to :: look for these days? My last PS was a 450W ATX from maybe 5 years :: ago. I expect my new one would have to be at least 500W now. :: :: I'm thinking I should get one with the low-speed 120 mm fans. And :: maybe one with a motherboard fan speed connector? For sure, Yousuf, if I was still living in the States I would be buying my PS from PC Power & Cooling. Check out the link: http://www.pcpower.com/index.html Geez, a PS from five years ago? Was this the PS involved with your computer that you posted problems with SATA drives, Nvidia chipsets and corruption? Hope not! Cheers. J. |
#3
|
|||
|
|||
Power supplies?
Jack wrote:
For sure, Yousuf, if I was still living in the States I would be buying my PS from PC Power & Cooling. Check out the link: http://www.pcpower.com/index.html Well, okay, I'll note that down. Know anything about Zalman PS's? Geez, a PS from five years ago? Was this the PS involved with your computer that you posted problems with SATA drives, Nvidia chipsets and corruption? Hope not! Cheers. Well, yes it's the same machine, since one of the suggestions was to replace the PS, I've decided to give that solution a shot. Looking at the specs these days, they seem to have multi-rail +12V support. They range from dual-rail upto quad-rail. Not sure whether to go with more or if two is enough? Yousuf Khan |
#4
|
|||
|
|||
Power supplies?
Yousuf Khan wrote:
:: Jack wrote: ::: For sure, Yousuf, if I was still living in the States I would be ::: buying my PS from PC Power & Cooling. Check out the link: ::: http://www.pcpower.com/index.html :: :: Well, okay, I'll note that down. :: :: Know anything about Zalman PS's? Never used one personally but friends who have built their own systems and installed Zalman seem to be happy with them. They have a good rep here in Spain. ::: Geez, a PS from five years ago? Was this the PS involved with ::: your computer that you posted problems with SATA drives, Nvidia ::: chipsets and corruption? Hope not! Cheers. :: :: :: Well, yes it's the same machine, since one of the suggestions was :: to replace the PS, I've decided to give that solution a shot. With the problems you posted and now the fact you're using a five year old PS, that's exactly what I'd do too. :: Looking at the specs these days, they seem to have multi-rail +12V :: support. They range from dual-rail upto quad-rail. Not sure :: whether to go with more or if two is enough? Hmmm. Read up on PC Power & Cooling's "Power Supply Myths Exposed." They seem to indicate multirail designs have at least one major drawback. Maybe DAYTRIPPER would jump in here??? http://www.pcpower.com/technology/myths/ J. |
#5
|
|||
|
|||
Power supplies?
On Mon, 23 Mar 2009 14:02:46 +0100, "Jack" wrote:
Yousuf Khan wrote: :: Jack wrote: ::: For sure, Yousuf, if I was still living in the States I would be ::: buying my PS from PC Power & Cooling. Check out the link: ::: http://www.pcpower.com/index.html :: :: Well, okay, I'll note that down. :: :: Know anything about Zalman PS's? Never used one personally but friends who have built their own systems and installed Zalman seem to be happy with them. They have a good rep here in Spain. ::: Geez, a PS from five years ago? Was this the PS involved with ::: your computer that you posted problems with SATA drives, Nvidia ::: chipsets and corruption? Hope not! Cheers. :: :: :: Well, yes it's the same machine, since one of the suggestions was :: to replace the PS, I've decided to give that solution a shot. With the problems you posted and now the fact you're using a five year old PS, that's exactly what I'd do too. :: Looking at the specs these days, they seem to have multi-rail +12V :: support. They range from dual-rail upto quad-rail. Not sure :: whether to go with more or if two is enough? Hmmm. Read up on PC Power & Cooling's "Power Supply Myths Exposed." They seem to indicate multirail designs have at least one major drawback. Maybe DAYTRIPPER would jump in here??? http://www.pcpower.com/technology/myths/ J. Not with both feet - too close to a religion discussion for me ;-) That PC P&C page is certainly as self-serving as possible, but there are utility tradeoffs in isolation vs flexibility between the two designs for which the user must account, regardless of any price advantage. In any case, at the end of the day, proper sizing for the intended configuration, and user-provided reliability history gleaned from any number of forums, are much more important than any implementation differences. /daytripper (That - plus blue leds ;-) |
#6
|
|||
|
|||
Power supplies?
On Mar 23, 9:02*am, "Jack" wrote:
:: Know anything about Zalman PS's? Never used one personally but friends who have built their own systems and installed Zalman seem to be happy with them. *They have a good rep here in Spain. Well, there is a deal on a refurbed Zalman PS that I've seen. ::: Geez, a PS from five years ago? *Was this the PS involved with ::: your computer that you posted problems with SATA drives, Nvidia ::: chipsets and corruption? Hope not! *Cheers. :: :: :: Well, yes it's the same machine, since one of the suggestions was :: to replace the PS, I've decided to give that solution a shot. With the problems you posted and now the fact you're using a five year old PS, that's exactly what I'd do too. I usually never replace my PS unless I get a new one with a new case or if the PS blows up due to an electrical storm or something. The one I have currently was relatively high-end for its time, 420W. It's gone through two processor and two GPU upgrades without any problems. So it seemed a little random that a simple hard drive addition should push it over the edge when previous processor and video upgrades didn't faze it. :: Looking at the specs these days, they seem to have multi-rail +12V :: support. They range from dual-rail upto quad-rail. Not sure :: whether to go with more or if two is enough? Hmmm. *Read up on PC Power & Cooling's "Power Supply Myths Exposed." *They seem to indicate multirail designs have at least one major drawback. *Maybe DAYTRIPPER would jump in here???http://www.pcpower.com/technology/myths/ I'll check it out. Yousuf Khan |
#7
|
|||
|
|||
Power supplies?
On Mar 23, 1:51*pm, daytripper wrote:
On Mon, 23 Mar 2009 14:02:46 +0100, "Jack" wrote: Hmmm. *Read up on PC Power & Cooling's "Power Supply Myths Exposed." *They seem to indicate multirail designs have at least one major drawback. *Maybe DAYTRIPPER would jump in here??? http://www.pcpower.com/technology/myths/ J. Not with both feet - too close to a religion discussion for me ;-) That PC P&C page is certainly as self-serving as possible, but there are utility tradeoffs in isolation vs flexibility between the two designs for which the user must account, regardless of any price advantage. Sure seemed like it. Are these excuses for their products not having all of the features these days? They're railing against multi-rail power supplies (pun), but doesn't the current ATX v2.x power supply specs require you to have at least two rails by default? In any case, at the end of the day, proper sizing for the intended configuration, and user-provided reliability history gleaned from any number of forums, are much more important than any implementation differences. /daytripper (That - plus blue leds ;-) All of the big high-end ones seem to have the blue LEDs these days. Yousuf Khan |
#8
|
|||
|
|||
Power supplies?
On Mon, 23 Mar 2009 11:48:17 -0700 (PDT), YKhan wrote:
On Mar 23, 1:51*pm, daytripper wrote: On Mon, 23 Mar 2009 14:02:46 +0100, "Jack" wrote: Hmmm. *Read up on PC Power & Cooling's "Power Supply Myths Exposed." *They seem to indicate multirail designs have at least one major drawback. *Maybe DAYTRIPPER would jump in here??? http://www.pcpower.com/technology/myths/ J. Not with both feet - too close to a religion discussion for me ;-) That PC P&C page is certainly as self-serving as possible, but there are utility tradeoffs in isolation vs flexibility between the two designs for which the user must account, regardless of any price advantage. Sure seemed like it. Are these excuses for their products not having all of the features these days? They're railing against multi-rail power supplies (pun), but doesn't the current ATX v2.x power supply specs require you to have at least two rails by default? In any case, at the end of the day, proper sizing for the intended configuration, and user-provided reliability history gleaned from any number of forums, are much more important than any implementation differences. /daytripper (That - plus blue leds ;-) All of the big high-end ones seem to have the blue LEDs these days. Yousuf Khan In spite of some rather mushy "should" statements early in the spec, a strong case could be made that the whole of ATX12V spec v2.2 absolutely requires more than one 12V rail - for capacity in excess of 18A. That 18A value is driven by the *requirement* of meeting UL & CSA safety 240VA regs: 3.2.4. Power Limit / Hazardous Energy Levels "Under normal or overload conditions, no output shall continuously provide more than 240 VA under any conditions of load including output short circuit, per the requirement of UL 1950/CSA 950 / EN 60950/IEC 950." The requirement to meet UL 1950/CSA 950 / EN 60950/IEC 950 is also provided in section 3.1.4 "Regulatory". fwiw, I've been using Rosewill supplies of late, particularly their RP600V2-S-SL 600W supply - which is a dual-12V rail design. I've built three well-loaded systems with these in the last couple of years with zero issues and think they provide good value... /daytripper |
#9
|
|||
|
|||
Power supplies?
daytripper wrote:
fwiw, I've been using Rosewill supplies of late, particularly their RP600V2-S-SL 600W supply - which is a dual-12V rail design. I've built three well-loaded systems with these in the last couple of years with zero issues and think they provide good value... That previous PC P&C "myths" article mentioned that having unused +12V rails would be a problem, as power supposedly gets trapped in the unused rails creating efficiency losses. Any truth in this stuff? I can't see how this might happen myself, a capacitor might get filled, and once it's filled no more electricity goes into it until it gets utilized. Yousuf Khan |
#10
|
|||
|
|||
Power supplies?
On Mon, 23 Mar 2009 17:13:29 -0400, Yousuf Khan wrote:
daytripper wrote: fwiw, I've been using Rosewill supplies of late, particularly their RP600V2-S-SL 600W supply - which is a dual-12V rail design. I've built three well-loaded systems with these in the last couple of years with zero issues and think they provide good value... That previous PC P&C "myths" article mentioned that having unused +12V rails would be a problem, as power supposedly gets trapped in the unused rails creating efficiency losses. Any truth in this stuff? I can't see how this might happen myself, a capacitor might get filled, and once it's filled no more electricity goes into it until it gets utilized. Yousuf Khan It's nothing that involved - there's no "trapped" electrons, and there's no real effect on "efficiency" in any classic sense. That whole spiel simply points out the effect of "partitioning" 12V capacity into multiple isolated rails, verses having all 12V capacity on a single rail. For instance, say you have a single-rail supply with 36A of 12V capacity, and another supply with 2 12V rails rated at 18A each. Now build a system that requires 12A of 12V for the motherboard and peripherals, plus a pair of 12A graphics cards. Both supplies are rated at 36A of 12V, but hooking up the dual-rail supply is probably going to be more challenging than the single rail supply. In fact, it probably could not be done - hence you would have unusable ("trapped") capacity in the dual-rail supply... /daytripper |
|
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
24-pin Power Supplies: What's going on? | aether | General Hardware | 5 | March 12th 05 04:55 PM |
Power Supplies | jc | General Hardware | 0 | February 20th 05 04:32 PM |
Need 12v 1a AC-DC Power supplies | ds | UK Computer Vendors | 5 | June 18th 04 07:01 PM |
PC Power & Cooling power supplies -- what parts are theirs? | G.W. Bush | General | 1 | March 8th 04 05:58 PM |
Power Supplies - Can anyone offer a quality opinion on Ultra Power Supplies please? - TIA | Pete | Overclocking AMD Processors | 8 | February 2nd 04 09:22 AM |