If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the FAQ by clicking the link above. You may have to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below. |
|
|
|
Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#1
|
|||
|
|||
College Computer --- Vista -vs- XP Pro
Our second daughter is going to college in the fall. I am starting to shop for her laptop. I am inclined to go with XP Pro, as I know it well, and have heard of numerous Vista problems. But SP1 is out, so perhaps those problems are history. How long would it be likely for me to learn how to maintain Vista (so I can teach her to do it)? What are the pros and cons of XP and Vista? Which version of Vista should I get? Does it have a built in System Restore backup like XP Pro? (I have used this several times, with no problems). Thanks in advance, -- Andrew Hall (Now reading Usenet in alt.sys.pc-clone.dell...) |
#2
|
|||
|
|||
College Computer --- Vista -vs- XP Pro
my kid is going into her third year, running xp pro without any need for
vista. wrote in message ... Our second daughter is going to college in the fall. I am starting to shop for her laptop. I am inclined to go with XP Pro, as I know it well, and have heard of numerous Vista problems. But SP1 is out, so perhaps those problems are history. How long would it be likely for me to learn how to maintain Vista (so I can teach her to do it)? What are the pros and cons of XP and Vista? Which version of Vista should I get? Does it have a built in System Restore backup like XP Pro? (I have used this several times, with no problems). Thanks in advance, -- Andrew Hall (Now reading Usenet in alt.sys.pc-clone.dell...) |
#3
|
|||
|
|||
College Computer --- Vista -vs- XP Pro
I have a dog in this hunt and it is XP Pro.
If you decide to go with Vista for some reason, check with the college to find out the minimum version they require. Many colleges register students' computers in the college domain, for which XP Pro works, as do some versions of Vista. If you go with Vista, spend and overspend on the hardware to make sure it will run well. It is pretty bloated. Every version of Windows gets more bloated than its predecessor. This is the Microsoft way. Always has been, Always will be. Vista can be considered the "Hardware Sales Act of 2007", although the US Congress did not legislate it. Had they done so and if I were president, I would have vetoed it. The "Hardware Sales Act of 2007" was the work of a special subcommitee consisting of representatives of Microsoft, Intel, AMD, the major memory manufacturers (read: glut of memory on the market), and all the major name brand computer assemblers (Dell, HPaq, eGateMachines, Lenovo, etc). I hesitate to call the latter manufacturers. if they are manufacturers, my garage and kitchen table together are a factory. Perhaps the big issue with Vista is dealing with its security, which is better than XP's (so they say), but also more tedious. You can also set up the Vista environment so that it looks a lot (almost identical) and works a lot like XP Pro... Ben Myers On 21 May 2008 09:50:46 -0400, wrote: Our second daughter is going to college in the fall. I am starting to shop for her laptop. I am inclined to go with XP Pro, as I know it well, and have heard of numerous Vista problems. But SP1 is out, so perhaps those problems are history. How long would it be likely for me to learn how to maintain Vista (so I can teach her to do it)? What are the pros and cons of XP and Vista? Which version of Vista should I get? Does it have a built in System Restore backup like XP Pro? (I have used this several times, with no problems). Thanks in advance, |
#4
|
|||
|
|||
College Computer --- Vista -vs- XP Pro
wrote in message ... Our second daughter is going to college in the fall. I am starting to shop for her laptop. I am inclined to go with XP Pro, as I know it well, and have heard of numerous Vista problems. But SP1 is out, so perhaps those problems are history. How long would it be likely for me to learn how to maintain Vista (so I can teach her to do it)? What are the pros and cons of XP and Vista? Which version of Vista should I get? Does it have a built in System Restore backup like XP Pro? (I have used this several times, with no problems). Thanks in advance, -- Andrew Hall (Now reading Usenet in alt.sys.pc-clone.dell...) Andrew, You might inquire about buying a business notebook for her (Vostro or Latitude) with the "WinXP Pro downgrade" option. I think this is supposed to be offered beginning in June. The short of that is the system will have XP Pro installed at the factory, but with a Windows Vista COA/license and installation DVD. In doing that, she can legally run XP Pro and then (if necessary in the future) legally install Vista should it be required. Stew |
#5
|
|||
|
|||
College Computer --- Vista -vs- XP Pro
Hi!
I am inclined to go with XP Pro, as I know it well, and have heard of numerous Vista problems. But SP1 is out, so perhaps those problems are history. I see no reason not to listen to your inclination. :-) Vista SP1 did fix a lot of problems, and did improve the speed of the OS. But it's not perfect, and unless you download the full installer, it may not be presented to you for a while via Windows Automatic Updating. (That is assuming that if you buy a computer now it will not have SP1. That may be erroneous. I'm not sure how many OEMs have updated their installation images with SP1.) How long would it be likely for me to learn how to maintain Vista (so I can teach her to do it)? I would plan on spending at least a week with it. What are the pros and cons of XP and Vista? Well, XP is much less bloated. Which means you wouldn't have to make such a huge investment in hardware...you could get away with a less expensive but still nice system and it would run well. XP is also mature, well established and stable. If you're going to chance Vista, I would agree with Ben Myers' suggestion--get dedicated video and at least 2GB RAM. A good and fast hard disk won't hurt either. Vista's bloat is the second biggest thing (in my view) that works against it. The first is the complete destruction of the Windows user interface and long established concepts that go with it. For me, that is a deal breaker. UAC (user account control) is annoying and I'm not sure it provides any security benefit whatsoever. (This is the "windows needs your permission to continue" feature, and Windows will probably get that permission from most users even if the screen says in big red flashing letters "This is a nasty virus that will destroy your computer!" Whoops. Sorry. That's my sysadmin side kicking in! :-) I'm trying to find something good to say about Vista--oh, yeah...Microsoft has significantly redesigned the system to be much more secure against common threats. Some of this is good stuff (Internet Explorer 7's restricted rights mode, where it runs at a low privilege level when you are using it) and some of it isn't (Windows Duh-fender, UAC). Which version of Vista should I get? Either of the Home versions (Premium or Basic) or Vista Business. Home Basic is fine if the end user of the system needs to do no more than browse the web, use e-mail and perform tasks like word processing, spreadsheeting, etc. Home Premium adds the "glitz" of Aero graphics and (I think) some Media Center features. A lot of people question the point of Vista Home Basic. I think it fills in a good spot in the marketplace for users that don't ever do a whole lot with their computer beyond basic tasks. Vista Business has Aero graphics and can be joined to a domain (if that's a requirement). It also has some features that are primarily useful in a business or commercial environment. About the only thing I wouldn't do is get Vista Ultimate. It's expensive and the extra cost really only gets you a few additional toys that don't show up in Vista Home Premium or Business editions. Does it have a built in System Restore backup like XP Pro? Yes, and it works pretty much the same way. William |
#6
|
|||
|
|||
College Computer --- Vista -vs- XP Pro
|
#7
|
|||
|
|||
College Computer --- Vista -vs- XP Pro
you should contact the school to see what they recommend. often college
campus partner with a particular vendor who maintains a repair shop on campus for speedy repairs. laptops are used these days in place of notebooks, are carried around most of the time and can get quite a workout. this all translates into greater potential need for repair. plus, it would be a real handicap to be without a computer for an extended period of time. i would go with xp pro, there is nothing compelling about vista other than the 'look' (and that is a debatable) and it does not perform as well. also, keep in mind that macs are the number one selling laptops on campus' these days. she may be happier with a macbook. both dell and apple have college 'stores' on their web sites where you can get a discount. but at dell these educational discounts are not always the best pricing available. wrote in message ... Our second daughter is going to college in the fall. I am starting to shop for her laptop. I am inclined to go with XP Pro, as I know it well, and have heard of numerous Vista problems. But SP1 is out, so perhaps those problems are history. How long would it be likely for me to learn how to maintain Vista (so I can teach her to do it)? What are the pros and cons of XP and Vista? Which version of Vista should I get? Does it have a built in System Restore backup like XP Pro? (I have used this several times, with no problems). Thanks in advance, -- Andrew Hall (Now reading Usenet in alt.sys.pc-clone.dell...) |
#8
|
|||
|
|||
College Computer --- Vista -vs- XP Pro
ps. by 'notebooks' i mean paper notebooks.
"Christoper Muto" wrote in message m... you should contact the school to see what they recommend. often college campus partner with a particular vendor who maintains a repair shop on campus for speedy repairs. laptops are used these days in place of notebooks, are carried around most of the time and can get quite a workout. this all translates into greater potential need for repair. plus, it would be a real handicap to be without a computer for an extended period of time. i would go with xp pro, there is nothing compelling about vista other than the 'look' (and that is a debatable) and it does not perform as well. also, keep in mind that macs are the number one selling laptops on campus' these days. she may be happier with a macbook. both dell and apple have college 'stores' on their web sites where you can get a discount. but at dell these educational discounts are not always the best pricing available. wrote in message ... Our second daughter is going to college in the fall. I am starting to shop for her laptop. I am inclined to go with XP Pro, as I know it well, and have heard of numerous Vista problems. But SP1 is out, so perhaps those problems are history. How long would it be likely for me to learn how to maintain Vista (so I can teach her to do it)? What are the pros and cons of XP and Vista? Which version of Vista should I get? Does it have a built in System Restore backup like XP Pro? (I have used this several times, with no problems). Thanks in advance, -- Andrew Hall (Now reading Usenet in alt.sys.pc-clone.dell...) |
#9
|
|||
|
|||
College Computer --- Vista -vs- XP Pro
On Wed, 21 May 2008 13:44:34 -0400, "Christoper Muto"
wrote: also, keep in mind that macs are the number one selling laptops on campus' these days. she may be happier with a macbook. If she does get a Mac, Windows XP can still be run virtually using VMWare or Parallels. I use VMWare and all of my programs and utilities run flawlessly. You'd need a legal XP install disk. If you do go with a Mac be aware that there will likely be a significant design change near the end of summer. The MacBooks will likely be all aluminum. Several Mac rumor sites concur and they are usually fairly accurate. I would recommend the Lenovo ThinkPad T61 laptop first, then a laptop in the Dell Latitude series if durability is important, or an ultra portable Lenovo ThinkPad X61 for portability, and a docking station. |
#10
|
|||
|
|||
College Computer --- Vista -vs- XP Pro
My take on this is that Vista may initially be problematic for the college
IT admins to get it to connect to their infrastructure. This is based on my daughter's experience last fall at Texas Womens University. That said, with another year under their belt I think that this next fall will find the university IT department more capable in handling Vista. Comments about having the capability to coexist in a university environment that uses domains are true, if you go to a university that requires this. Then XP Pro or Vista Business/Ultimate would be required. My observation is that there are often workarounds for students off-campus who cannot easily jack into the university's infrastructure. YMMV. What has really bugged my daughter isn't Vista (although she thinks it is) it is Office 2007. All the menu structures are hosed when compared to, say, Office 2000. The default doc is .xml, or some variant instead of .doc. This has caused my daughter no end of frustration (she blames it on 'Vista'). If you have a choice, don't let her use Office 2007. My guess is that the .doc format will be around for the remainder of her college career and if she is already used to it, why ask for troulbe. Mike wrote in message ... Our second daughter is going to college in the fall. I am starting to shop for her laptop. I am inclined to go with XP Pro, as I know it well, and have heard of numerous Vista problems. But SP1 is out, so perhaps those problems are history. How long would it be likely for me to learn how to maintain Vista (so I can teach her to do it)? What are the pros and cons of XP and Vista? Which version of Vista should I get? Does it have a built in System Restore backup like XP Pro? (I have used this several times, with no problems). Thanks in advance, -- Andrew Hall (Now reading Usenet in alt.sys.pc-clone.dell...) |
|
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
Want to build a nice Vista computer | [email protected] | Asus Motherboards | 9 | May 15th 07 04:10 AM |
Beware of VISTA if you have any multimedia aspirations with your computer | Rich | AMD x86-64 Processors | 12 | February 18th 07 05:51 AM |
GeForce for an old computer and Vista requirements? | BarMan | General | 15 | December 7th 06 01:04 AM |
College computer | nb | Dell Computers | 27 | October 9th 05 06:18 AM |
Need planning help for daughter's college computer | Ken K | Homebuilt PC's | 12 | June 29th 04 06:21 AM |