Overland NEO4100 vs ADIC Scalar 100 & CommVault Galaxy Vs Legato Networker

Hi all,

We are looking to backup 3 windows boxes...

1 x Win 2003 SATA RAID box (Up to 8TB Storage) - OEM Solution
1 x Exchange 2000 (10GB DB)
1 x W2K DC (Active Directory) - Small AD DB!

We have a 48 backup window (with verification) to backup our current
3TB raw data, exchange and AD DB.

The two resellers, which for obvious reasons I will not quote have
come up with the following specs...

Reseller 1...

Overland NEO 4100 / LTO2 x2 / 60 data slots, & 1-slot mailbox
(£19,000)

CommVault Galaxy backup (£8,500)...

1 Universal Edition CommServe StorageManager for a Windows server.
1 MediaAgent for a Windows NT or 2000 server.
2 x Drive Management Software (priced per drive)
1 iDataAgent for an Active Directory Server.
1 iDataAgent (mailbox level) for an Exchange Server.
1 iDataAgent for Windows Server (NT, W2K, W2K3).
1 license for Open File Manager for Windows Server.

5 Days install & handover

Reseller 2...

ADIC Scalar 100 / LTO2 x2 /60 data slots & 12-slot mailbox. (£15,000)

NetWorker Server for W2K/NT, Includes 9 clients - (£11,000)
Auto Changer 1-60 Slots
NetWorker Module for Microsoft Exchange Server, Windows Client, Tier 2
NetWorker Open File Manager, 1 Client, Server, Windows and NetWare
Legato Media Kit

5 Days install & handover

-------------
Your comments, suggestions on the hardware, software and pricing would
be very much appreciated!

Thanks!