If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the FAQ by clicking the link above. You may have to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below. |
|
|
Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#1
|
|||
|
|||
Power on issue - revisited
I have a very similar question to a previous poster.
(But, I decided not to clutter up that note so I'll start this new one.) Ok. One has a new case. One adds a power supply with a fan inside that power-supply. Before even a mother-board or anything else is added, one puts a power cord into the back of the power supply and moves the rocker switch on the power-supply to the on (aka the '1' position). Should the fan in the power supply come on? Should I be able to measure power in the connectors hanging off the power supply? (Or does logic from either the front-panel switch and/or the motherboard's BIOS chip have to be present and fed back somewhere before the power supply lets power be fed around?) Dave |
#2
|
|||
|
|||
On Mon, 3 Nov 2003 17:15:38 -0500, "David Cook" (who wants to know?)
wrote: I have a very similar question to a previous poster. (But, I decided not to clutter up that note so I'll start this new one.) Ok. One has a new case. One adds a power supply with a fan inside that power-supply. Before even a mother-board or anything else is added, one puts a power cord into the back of the power supply and moves the rocker switch on the power-supply to the on (aka the '1' position). Should the fan in the power supply come on? On an ATX, no. It will not come on. Should I be able to measure power in the connectors hanging off the power supply? Only 5vsb, the standby voltage. Not a good idea to run a PSU with no load anyway. Probably won't hurt anything unless it is a very cheap PSU, but the voltage readings don't mean much without a reasonable load. 5V no load might be 4.5V under load. Good PSU will not show much variation, but with no load you don't know. (Or does logic from either the front-panel switch and/or the motherboard's BIOS chip have to be present and fed back somewhere before the power supply lets power be fed around?) The motherboard pulls a pin on the connector low (do a search on groups.google.com on testing powersupplies to find out which). The Power switch is a soft switch that acts through the motherboard logic. Dave JT |
#3
|
|||
|
|||
David Cook wrote:
Ok. One has a new case. One adds a power supply with a fan inside that power-supply. Before even a mother-board or anything else is added, one puts a power cord into the back of the power supply and moves the rocker switch on the power-supply to the on (aka the '1' position). Should the fan in the power supply come on? If ATX, no. Should I be able to measure power in the connectors hanging off the power supply? If ATX, no (except the +5vsb on pin 9.) (Or does logic from either the front-panel switch and/or the motherboard's BIOS chip have to be present and fed back somewhere before the power supply lets power be fed around?) Pin 14 on the 20 pin connector must be pulled 0.6v. To test an ATX PSU: First, disconnect everything from the power supply (including MB.) Plug AC cord into the rear of the PS. IF the PS has its own rocker on/off switch, turn it ON. There should be +5v on pin 9 of the 20 pin connector (+5vsb, usually a violet wire.) There should be 0.8v on pin 14 (PS-ON, usually a green wire.) This is from an internal pull-up to the +5vsb. Connect PS power leads to 1 or 2 IDE HDs (for a load). Jumper pin 14 (PS-ON) to pin 13 (ground, black wire.) At this point, fan in PS should start spinning, drives should spin, and + 5/12v, -5/12v, +3.3v, and +5vsb should be present at 20 pin connector. Disconnecting pin 14-13 jumper should turn supply back off. |
#4
|
|||
|
|||
On Mon, 3 Nov 2003 17:15:38 -0500, "David Cook" (who wants to know?)
wrote: I have a very similar question to a previous poster. (But, I decided not to clutter up that note so I'll start this new one.) Ok. One has a new case. One adds a power supply with a fan inside that power-supply. Before even a mother-board or anything else is added, one puts a power cord into the back of the power supply and moves the rocker switch on the power-supply to the on (aka the '1' position). Should the fan in the power supply come on? Should I be able to measure power in the connectors hanging off the power supply? (Or does logic from either the front-panel switch and/or the motherboard's BIOS chip have to be present and fed back somewhere before the power supply lets power be fed around?) Dave I'm going to skip the answer since previous poster covered it, and start with questions: Why do you want to know, what's the problem? Is it a name-brand power supply or unknown generic? I would be very happy to know of even one unknown generic that's a decent power supply, but so far, NONE are. The larger power supply manufacturers buy parts in bulk, secure volume contracts for quality parts, spec for workstations/servers as well as PCs, and have a trickle-down effect such that a good power supply for a PC costs less to make, plus they want their name only on decent hardware. Dave |
#5
|
|||
|
|||
There are at least two reason that I want to understand this.
I saw an 'empty' case with power-supply that was rigged up with some spooky lights inside a case that has a plexiglass side panel, so you can see (red, blue, green) lights illuminate the inside of this case. So, I purchased the empty case, an ATX power-supply, and a couple of these lights, and an instruction sheet, but quickly realized after I brought it home that I was sorely lacking in conceptual knowledge as to the theory behind the wiring. (The display model in the store is plugged in and the lights come on when the power-supply is turned on. But, there is no mother-board in the display model at all.) So, based on what you posters have said, I now know that some jumpering of wires is probably being done. (Actually, I do NOT recall now whether the FANS were on.) These lights probably need only 5-volts to drive them? Another reason I wanted to know was that I had a machine go dead (would NOT power up) last week, and since I had no clue at all how to trouble-shoot that problem, I had to shell out money to a fixit place just to learn whether I had a power-supply/ power-switch problem or a mother-board failure. (They first diagnosed it as the front panel swtich, replaced that, I took it home, it STILL would not power up, took it back, and they now tell me I have a bad motherboard. I'm starting to understand now why it took them 1.5 hours of labor and two tries just to get to this point.) Hope this satisfies the curiosity about why I wanted to understand this stuff better. Cheers... Dave "kony" wrote in message news On Mon, 3 Nov 2003 17:15:38 -0500, "David Cook" (who wants to know?) wrote: I have a very similar question to a previous poster. (But, I decided not to clutter up that note so I'll start this new one.) Ok. One has a new case. One adds a power supply with a fan inside that power-supply. Before even a mother-board or anything else is added, one puts a power cord into the back of the power supply and moves the rocker switch on the power-supply to the on (aka the '1' position). Should the fan in the power supply come on? Should I be able to measure power in the connectors hanging off the power supply? (Or does logic from either the front-panel switch and/or the motherboard's BIOS chip have to be present and fed back somewhere before the power supply lets power be fed around?) Dave I'm going to skip the answer since previous poster covered it, and start with questions: Why do you want to know, what's the problem? Is it a name-brand power supply or unknown generic? I would be very happy to know of even one unknown generic that's a decent power supply, but so far, NONE are. The larger power supply manufacturers buy parts in bulk, secure volume contracts for quality parts, spec for workstations/servers as well as PCs, and have a trickle-down effect such that a good power supply for a PC costs less to make, plus they want their name only on decent hardware. Dave |
#6
|
|||
|
|||
Ric (or anyone else) -
Thanks for the very detailed explanation! Which brings me to a related question: How do you folks come by this knowledge? (Yeah, school of hard knocks, I know.) What I really mean to ask is: Is there a single book (or website) where the majority of this kind of information can be found? (I've been building my own machines from motherboards for years, but have never needed to venture over into hardware diagnosis/repair until just a week or so ago.) TIA... Dave "ric" wrote in message ... David Cook wrote: Ok. One has a new case. One adds a power supply with a fan inside that power-supply. Before even a mother-board or anything else is added, one puts a power cord into the back of the power supply and moves the rocker switch on the power-supply to the on (aka the '1' position). Should the fan in the power supply come on? If ATX, no. Should I be able to measure power in the connectors hanging off the power supply? If ATX, no (except the +5vsb on pin 9.) (Or does logic from either the front-panel switch and/or the motherboard's BIOS chip have to be present and fed back somewhere before the power supply lets power be fed around?) Pin 14 on the 20 pin connector must be pulled 0.6v. To test an ATX PSU: First, disconnect everything from the power supply (including MB.) Plug AC cord into the rear of the PS. IF the PS has its own rocker on/off switch, turn it ON. There should be +5v on pin 9 of the 20 pin connector (+5vsb, usually a violet wire.) There should be 0.8v on pin 14 (PS-ON, usually a green wire.) This is from an internal pull-up to the +5vsb. Connect PS power leads to 1 or 2 IDE HDs (for a load). Jumper pin 14 (PS-ON) to pin 13 (ground, black wire.) At this point, fan in PS should start spinning, drives should spin, and + 5/12v, -5/12v, +3.3v, and +5vsb should be present at 20 pin connector. Disconnecting pin 14-13 jumper should turn supply back off. |
#7
|
|||
|
|||
David Cook wrote:
Ric (or anyone else) - Thanks for the very detailed explanation! Which brings me to a related question: How do you folks come by this knowledge? (Yeah, school of hard knocks, I know.) Being involved in power supply R&D, design, manufacture, and test for over 20 years? Being in charge of tech support for a company that builds PC PSUs? "ric" wrote in message ... David Cook wrote: Ok. One has a new case. One adds a power supply with a fan inside that power-supply. Before even a mother-board or anything else is added, one puts a power cord into the back of the power supply and moves the rocker switch on the power-supply to the on (aka the '1' position). Should the fan in the power supply come on? If ATX, no. Should I be able to measure power in the connectors hanging off the power supply? If ATX, no (except the +5vsb on pin 9.) (Or does logic from either the front-panel switch and/or the motherboard's BIOS chip have to be present and fed back somewhere before the power supply lets power be fed around?) Pin 14 on the 20 pin connector must be pulled 0.6v. To test an ATX PSU: First, disconnect everything from the power supply (including MB.) Plug AC cord into the rear of the PS. IF the PS has its own rocker on/off switch, turn it ON. There should be +5v on pin 9 of the 20 pin connector (+5vsb, usually a violet wire.) There should be 0.8v on pin 14 (PS-ON, usually a green wire.) This is from an internal pull-up to the +5vsb. Connect PS power leads to 1 or 2 IDE HDs (for a load). Jumper pin 14 (PS-ON) to pin 13 (ground, black wire.) At this point, fan in PS should start spinning, drives should spin, and + 5/12v, -5/12v, +3.3v, and +5vsb should be present at 20 pin connector. Disconnecting pin 14-13 jumper should turn supply back off. |
#8
|
|||
|
|||
http://www.formfactors.org/formfactor.asp
and Google groups search of alt.comp.hardware power supplies. http://makeashorterlink.com/?M34721F66 A good place to start. Lane |
#9
|
|||
|
|||
On Mon, 3 Nov 2003 21:08:20 -0500, "David Cook" (who wants to know?)
wrote: There are at least two reason that I want to understand this. I saw an 'empty' case with power-supply that was rigged up with some spooky lights inside a case that has a plexiglass side panel, so you can see (red, blue, green) lights illuminate the inside of this case. What, exactly, are these lights, or at least, what is the technology behind them, for example: LED, Cold-Cathode, Neon, plain old bulb So, I purchased the empty case, an ATX power-supply, and a couple of these lights, and an instruction sheet, but quickly realized after I brought it home that I was sorely lacking in conceptual knowledge as to the theory behind the wiring. (The display model in the store is plugged in and the lights come on when the power-supply is turned on. But, there is no mother-board in the display model at all.) Are you 100% sure there was only that much to the case/system? Often a display model of something can have additional misc. parts to make it do it's "thing". In this case there might've been a rigged connector plugged into the power supply, that shorted the PS_ON line to ground and perhaps a load on the 5V rail, dpending on what rail, how much power the lights use. This wouldn't be needed in a system with motherboard/etc, only to correctly wire up the lights. So, based on what you posters have said, I now know that some jumpering of wires is probably being done. (Actually, I do NOT recall now whether the FANS were on.) These lights probably need only 5-volts to drive them? Perhaps I'm assuming you want this to be a whole system but you did only want a case with no motherboard? I don't know about 5V, there's not much that uses 5V BUT an LED-type could use either 5V or 12V, depending on the size of the included resistor, and the lighting design... if in doubt always try the lower voltage before the higher one. Another reason I wanted to know was that I had a machine go dead (would NOT power up) last week, and since I had no clue at all how to trouble-shoot that problem, I had to shell out money to a fixit place just to learn whether I had a power-supply/ power-switch problem or a mother-board failure. If they couldn't narrow it down more than that, you were taken for money with no proper diagnosis... it's very easy to determine if it's the motherboard or the switch, just remove the switch plug and jumper or short the pins with something metal. However, only the most severly damaged motherboard won't turn on a properly working power supply, or of course if the board or wiring is shorted. (They first diagnosed it as the front panel swtich, replaced that, I took it home, it STILL would not power up, took it back, and they now tell me I have a bad motherboard. I'm starting to understand now why it took them 1.5 hours of labor and two tries just to get to this point.) In less than 1/2 hour they should've been able to swap in a different PSU and switch for testing, have a definitive diagnosis. You were taken by an incompetent shop. IMHO, they shouldn't have gotten a penny if they can't even diagnose something this simple, but maybe they didn't even have a single decent (spare) power supply to try, only junk. Many shops do use junk PSU unless something else is special-ordered. Hope this satisfies the curiosity about why I wanted to understand this stuff better. Cheers... Half the time a shop diagnoses a bad board, it's a junk power supply. The rest of the time it could be a number of things, the board or a BIOS setting or dead video card or hard drive or... The good old swap-in-better-power-supply test is the easiest way, but certainly NOT the same make/model, if it's junk. If the power supply is a generic I'd go ahead and replace it anyway, even if it turns out to be the motherboard. Also I already mentioned how to test the switch, just unplug it and short the appropriate two pins, are in the motherboard manual or silk-screened on the board itself right under the appropriate pins. Dave |
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
Silent Computer - Advice | David Taylor | General | 49 | October 7th 03 11:26 AM |
How can I make motherboard to restart after power loss automatically? | Amiran | General | 1 | September 24th 03 11:35 PM |
Power Supply on its way out? | w_tom | General | 5 | July 31st 03 03:43 PM |
Power Supply Gone Bad? | John | General | 4 | July 22nd 03 08:42 PM |
No power light or boot starting with ATX switch. Reset starts it fine? | Wayne Morgan | General | 2 | July 14th 03 05:25 AM |