If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the FAQ by clicking the link above. You may have to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below. |
|
|
Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#1
|
|||
|
|||
Firewire vs. IDE Hard drives
This is for small office windows workstations:
I have a Workstation with a SCSI harddrive and want to add a large capacity (100Gb, not too expensive) storage. I was thinking of IDE. But, I have been reading about Firewire and am wondering if I should seriously consider external Firewire Harddrives as they are not that expensive and should be portable too. I am probably a little behind on the new technologies but - is it time to completely drop IDE (at least for additional storage) and start using Firewire? Once again, this if for small office, not home use. Any drawbacks on using Firewire Harddrives (vs. IDE)? Thanks, Jay |
#2
|
|||
|
|||
On Tue, 16 Dec 2003 15:06:08 GMT, "Jay" wrote:
This is for small office windows workstations: I have a Workstation with a SCSI harddrive and want to add a large capacity (100Gb, not too expensive) storage. I was thinking of IDE. But, I have been reading about Firewire and am wondering if I should seriously consider external Firewire Harddrives as they are not that expensive and should be portable too. I am probably a little behind on the new technologies but - is it time to completely drop IDE (at least for additional storage) and start using Firewire? Once again, this if for small office, not home use. Any drawbacks on using Firewire Harddrives (vs. IDE)? Thanks, Jay Do you NEED it portable? That's pretty much the sole determining factor, then weight that against the odds that if it were portable, someone might walk off with it. As for drawbacks, it's slower, more expensive, louder, uses another outlet and more space... all worthwhile compromises if you need it somewhere else, but on the other hand I'd expect you have a network so it's not like it can't be shared if an internal? Dave |
#3
|
|||
|
|||
USB 2.0 is used more commonly than Firewire, and is just as fast.
-- DaveW "Jay" wrote in message . com... This is for small office windows workstations: I have a Workstation with a SCSI harddrive and want to add a large capacity (100Gb, not too expensive) storage. I was thinking of IDE. But, I have been reading about Firewire and am wondering if I should seriously consider external Firewire Harddrives as they are not that expensive and should be portable too. I am probably a little behind on the new technologies but - is it time to completely drop IDE (at least for additional storage) and start using Firewire? Once again, this if for small office, not home use. Any drawbacks on using Firewire Harddrives (vs. IDE)? Thanks, Jay |
#4
|
|||
|
|||
kony wrote:
On Tue, 16 Dec 2003 15:06:08 GMT, "Jay" wrote: This is for small office windows workstations: I have a Workstation with a SCSI harddrive and want to add a large capacity (100Gb, not too expensive) storage. I was thinking of IDE. But, I have been reading about Firewire and am wondering if I should seriously consider external Firewire Harddrives as they are not that expensive and should be portable too. I am probably a little behind on the new technologies but - is it time to completely drop IDE (at least for additional storage) and start using Firewire? Once again, this if for small office, not home use. Any drawbacks on using Firewire Harddrives (vs. IDE)? Thanks, Jay Do you NEED it portable? That's pretty much the sole determining factor, then weight that against the odds that if it were portable, someone might walk off with it. As for drawbacks, it's slower, Are you sure? I thought firewire was at 400Mbit/s which even converted to MB/s should be enough to deal with todays drives? A year ago they were getting 40MBs out of them. -- Stacey |
#5
|
|||
|
|||
On Tue, 16 Dec 2003 23:58:03 -0500, stacey wrote:
kony wrote: On Tue, 16 Dec 2003 15:06:08 GMT, "Jay" wrote: This is for small office windows workstations: I have a Workstation with a SCSI harddrive and want to add a large capacity (100Gb, not too expensive) storage. I was thinking of IDE. But, I have been reading about Firewire and am wondering if I should seriously consider external Firewire Harddrives as they are not that expensive and should be portable too. I am probably a little behind on the new technologies but - is it time to completely drop IDE (at least for additional storage) and start using Firewire? Once again, this if for small office, not home use. Any drawbacks on using Firewire Harddrives (vs. IDE)? Thanks, Jay Do you NEED it portable? That's pretty much the sole determining factor, then weight that against the odds that if it were portable, someone might walk off with it. As for drawbacks, it's slower, Are you sure? I thought firewire was at 400Mbit/s which even converted to MB/s should be enough to deal with todays drives? A year ago they were getting 40MBs out of them. I'm sure that some (if not all now) typical, relatively new (consider 12 months old or less) 7K2 ATA100 & ATA133 drives exceed 400Mbit/s, sustained thoughput. When talking about a newer drive with 8MB cache, it's even more of a bottleneck... even on the evil Via chipsets. ;-) Ignoring the firewire throuhput though, consider what you have... a bridge chip with a buffer... it is inherant that it be slower even if firewire was 30X as fast as internal ATA. I don't have any figures on how much of a penalty that incurs, but any penalty is an additional slowdown. Dave |
#6
|
|||
|
|||
"stacey" wrote in message
... kony wrote: On Tue, 16 Dec 2003 15:06:08 GMT, "Jay" wrote: This is for small office windows workstations: I have a Workstation with a SCSI harddrive and want to add a large capacity (100Gb, not too expensive) storage. I was thinking of IDE. But, I have been reading about Firewire and am wondering if I should seriously consider external Firewire Harddrives as they are not that expensive and should be portable too. I am probably a little behind on the new technologies but - is it time to completely drop IDE (at least for additional storage) and start using Firewire? Once again, this if for small office, not home use. Any drawbacks on using Firewire Harddrives (vs. IDE)? Thanks, Jay Do you NEED it portable? That's pretty much the sole determining factor, then weight that against the odds that if it were portable, someone might walk off with it. As for drawbacks, it's slower, Are you sure? I thought firewire was at 400Mbit/s which even converted to MB/s should be enough to deal with todays drives? A year ago they were getting 40MBs out of them. -- Stacey Nah. The actual drive INSIDE that shiny Firewire external case is an IDE drive of the same sort that you'd install internally in your computer. And often they aren't even the better quality drives since fast IDE drives put of a good bit of heat and the little external cases aren't always able to dissipate heat very well. So even if the Firewire is able to handle the data quickly it can't do anything to make the drive inside do the same so everything slows to a (relative) crawl. If somebody needs extra storage + portability then the external cases, either Firewire or USB 2 are able to handle the necessary data rate easily. But for speed an internal drive will always be as fast, or faster because a 10Krpm can be chosen, and cheaper. -- John McGaw [Knoxville, TN, USA] Return address will not work. Please reply in group or through my website: http://johnmcgaw.com |
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
Multi-boot Windows XP without special software | Timothy Daniels | General | 11 | December 12th 03 05:38 AM |
Vendor Warning! Monarch Computer - Samsung SP1614N 160gb hard disk drives | Steve Hawkins Jr | General | 2 | October 25th 03 03:43 AM |
Adding ATA 133 Controller Card | Michael L. Coleman | General | 4 | September 21st 03 07:20 AM |
Maxtor hard drives - don't surface scan! | CK | General | 3 | August 22nd 03 10:45 AM |
newb questions about SCSI hard drives | fred.do | General | 7 | June 26th 03 01:59 AM |