PDA

View Full Version : Re: ti4600 or fx5200


[NAC]Nubi
July 6th 03, 10:53 PM
well first of all your compairing a dx9 card to a dx8 card, next the fx5200
would be closer in comparison to a ti4200, someone else wanna explain? gotta
paint the kitchen today :(

> wrote in message
...
> whats the best card to get at the moment? fx5200 or gf4 ti4600? Ive
> tried an fx5200 in my system and i get 6997 3d marks with 3dmark01. My
> system is an athlon xp 2400+ with 512mb ddr ram
> #
>
> thanks

Flow
July 7th 03, 12:12 AM
I got 12000 score with ti4400
Go get the ti4600.....................................
MSI Kt3 ultra
amd xp2400+ no oc'ing
corsair xms 512mb ddr 333mhz.c2
Asus gf4 ti4400 128mb core 300mhz. mem 600mhz det.41.09
realtek ethernet card 1
realtek ethernet card 2
SB live soundblaster
56kpci modem v92 trust
liteon dvd player
hp 9300i cd writer
floppy drive
ibm deskstar 60gig 7200rpm
superflower 420w psu with aopen h600 case.
Win98se with all updates.

"Inglo" > schreef in bericht
.com...
> cam up with this on 7/6/2003 2:14 PM:
>
> >whats the best card to get at the moment? fx5200 or gf4 ti4600? Ive
> >tried an fx5200 in my system and i get 6997 3d marks with 3dmark01. My
> >system is an athlon xp 2400+ with 512mb ddr ram
> >#
> >
> >thanks
> >
> >
> Ti4600 for speed, you'll get nearly double the 3DMark01 score.
> FX5600 is DirectX 9 compliant, which doesn't really mean too much right
now.
> The *best* card to get at the moment is an ATI 9800 or nV FX 5900.
>
> --
> "I've got blisters on me fingers"
>
> Steve [Inglo]
>

Papaman
July 7th 03, 08:21 PM
Well considering the 4600 is ALOT faster than the 5200..
I'd go with the 4600. Its still a great video card.
I get close to 7700 with the FX5200 on my system (see below) and just over
13000 with the 4600.
That should tell you something.

Athlon 2500 Barton CPU
1 gig 2700 mhz DDRram
MSI KT3 Ultra mb
yadda yadda yadda..

Papaman

> wrote in message
...
> whats the best card to get at the moment? fx5200 or gf4 ti4600? Ive
> tried an fx5200 in my system and i get 6997 3d marks with 3dmark01. My
> system is an athlon xp 2400+ with 512mb ddr ram
> #
>
> thanks

Chimera
July 8th 03, 03:34 AM
I would think also the price difference would be quite significant!
Rule of thumb with graphics cards is that you get what you pay for, so more
bucks usually means more bang.

Larry Roberts
July 8th 03, 05:15 AM
On Sun, 06 Jul 2003 22:14:51 +0100, wrote:

>whats the best card to get at the moment? fx5200 or gf4 ti4600? Ive
>tried an fx5200 in my system and i get 6997 3d marks with 3dmark01. My
>system is an athlon xp 2400+ with 512mb ddr ram
>#
>
>thanks

I have an AMD Athlon XP 1900+, 256MB PC2100, GeForce 3 Ti200,
and WinME, and I got a score near 6900. The FX 5200 is around GF3
Ti200 performance. The FX 5200 Ultra is problably near a GF3 Ti500.
The GF4 Ti4600 will be alot faster. The only thing the FX 5200 has on
the GF4 Ti series is that it supports DirectX 9 shaders.